Can't we just make the battle system like FFXI's?

[Physic]

cop was pretty good, team strategies were pretty decent, but personal battle, as in what you actually do, was pretty bad. SCs were cool, but the weaponskill design itself didnt work well with using skill chains well. Basically in FFXI you only had one good weapon skill at a time usually, based on you /thf or war, multi hit or single target, so selecting any other weapon skill to make a specific magic burst was usually pretty bad.

But really im talking about battle itself, not strategy, We may employ some great straegies in dynamis pulling a group of mobs, 1 tank on the NM 2nd tank and DDs killing mobs in order of most dangerous, making sure spacing was proper, while mages sleep/nuke and healers heal. Great strategy as a team. But for each player, tank is doing same voke wait for tp WS probably, DD are all doing wait for tp WS, rdm are pressing thier buff refresh macros and their debuff mob macro. not exciting in terms of actual battle on personal level.

[Demacia]

cop was pretty good, team strategies were pretty decent, but personal battle, as in what you actually do, was pretty bad. SCs were cool, but the weaponskill design itself didnt work well with using skill chains well. Basically in FFXI you only had one good weapon skill at a time usually, based on you /thf or war, multi hit or single target, so selecting any other weapon skill to make a specific magic burst was usually pretty bad.

But really im talking about battle itself, not strategy, We may employ some great straegies in dynamis pulling a group of mobs, 1 tank on the NM 2nd tank and DDs killing mobs in order of most dangerous, making sure spacing was proper, while mages sleep/nuke and healers heal. Great strategy as a team. But for each player, tank is doing same voke wait for tp WS probably, DD are all doing wait for tp WS, rdm are pressing thier buff refresh macros and their debuff mob macro. not exciting in terms of actual battle on personal level.

That honestly depends on the job you're playing and the situation you're in. Even in a basic exp party, a MNK is not nearly as involved as a SCH would be. Also I don't know what kind of tanks you're used to that only voke and TP for WS.

[Physic]

That honestly depends on the job you're playing and the situation you're in. Even in a basic exp party, a MNK is not nearly as involved as a SCH would be. Also I don't know what kind of tanks you're used to that only voke and TP for WS.

im simplifying, but tanking was very boring, tanking basically does revovle around voke and tp for WS maybe throw in a sentinel every couple of minutes, or cure yourself, but it was pretty much same thing as being a DD. voke flash tp WS there is a reason that people were able to quad box and be just as good as a group of single players in that game. Blink tanking actually involved counting shadows, so it was slightly more complex but overall, still pretty much do nothing battle systems.

There were some jobs that required more things to do, but overall each job was pretty empty battlewise. It basically felt like you were in an offline rpg which had 5 players, but you only had control over one, which for me was not that exciting.

far as the jobs they added later, they had better mechanics and involvement,corsair, dancer blue mage, scholar, even pup all had thier own playstyle and differing mechanics. more things to do rather than wait for tp and use WS. they were honestly better designed than all that came before it. Even with the tweaks over the years, the initial jobs were basically still the same.

[Micronowski]

im simplifying, but tanking was very boring, tanking basically does revovle around voke and tp for WS maybe throw in a sentinel every couple of minutes, or cure yourself, but it was pretty much same thing as being a DD. voke flash tp WS there is a reason that people were able to quad box and be just as good as a group of single players in that game. Blink tanking actually involved counting shadows, so it was slightly more complex but overall, still pretty much do nothing battle systems.

There were some jobs that required more things to do, but overall each job was pretty empty battlewise. It basically felt like you were in an offline rpg which had 5 players, but you only had control over one, which for me was not that exciting.

far as the jobs they added later, they had better mechanics and involvement,corsair, dancer blue mage, scholar, even pup all had thier own playstyle and differing mechanics. more things to do rather than wait for tp and use WS. they were honestly better designed than all that came before it. Even with the tweaks over the years, the initial jobs were basically still the same.

NIN, and the occasional THF tank, would beg to differ as they had quite a lot to manage at times. Also, aren't you contradicting yourself by admitting the later jobs had more depth? This only reinforces the notion that they learned from their mistakes and can successfully evolve the FFXI battle system for XIV.

[Physic]

NIN, and the occasional THF tank, would beg to differ as they had quite a lot to manage at times. Also, aren't you contradicting yourself by admitting the later jobs had more depth? This only reinforces the notion that they learned from their mistakes and can successfully evolve the FFXI battle system for XIV.

Im not really trying to win an argument, im just having a discussion on the merits of ffxi battle system. The evolution of the FFXI battle system may be good, but if it were to evolve how i see it, i wouldnt describe it as being ffxi like. The title of the thread is make the battle like FFXI, which i still say had poor battle, although later classes were better, they were just a step in the right direction, not quite there.

FFXIV current battle actually offers a lot of the good parts about these jobs

Dancer, gets rid of the use all tp for every skill concept, now you can build tp and use it for skills.
Blue mage Has a very large move list, that you can equip to customize the playstyle of your charachter
Scholar, has active techniques and can fulfill various rolls as a mage and switch between them

each of these jobs also had different mechanics over all, they werent the same as another class, with different WS or Spells.
These type of things are incorporated into this battle system, added to that they have active skill management, not like early ffxi where you do a buff once every 5 minutes, you actively maintain or choose whats going on, you dont have random counters, you dodge, then hit counter, you actually tell the game to block.

The evolution of ffxi battle, as i see it, is pretty close to what we have in 14, im not saying there is nothing to be learned from ffxi, im saying they already learned it.

The only thing i think they are missing, is further diffrentiating playstyle between the classes, not by making WS specific, but making actual differences, much like bluemage was basically totally different than anything else. Of course, this may have already been planned with more guild marks skills. the free skills is what really defines a discipline.

I guess the question is really what exactly about ffxi battle system do you want to bring back?