This how i feel tanking as a Warrior^^

[Hachiko]

You're ignoring the 15% incoming healing boost that Warriors can sustain almost indefinitely. That counts for more than you may realise.

Indefinitely? Meaning you only inner beast once per minute?

And 15% counts, but it's still is a far cry from the 25% effective healing increase Paladin gets 100% of the time.

[AridElf]

Indefinitely? Meaning you only inner beast once per minute?

And 15% counts, but it's still is a far cry from the 25% effective healing increase Paladin gets 100% of the time.

I don't use Inner Beast when I don't need to. I don't see where you're getting this 25% effective healing that the Paladin gets. If you are referring to the -20% damage received while using Shield Oath then remember that Warriors get +25% HP while in Defiance. Yes the shield helps them out too but I would rather have a definite HP buffer than a randomly activated shield block.

[CurlyBruce]

I don't see where you're getting this 25% effective healing that the Paladin gets. If you are referring to the -20% damage received while using Shield Oath then remember that Warriors get +25% HP while in Defiance.

Yes, but there in lies the problem. -20% damage taken is equivalent to a +25% to effective HP. But because your visible HP isn't actually going up this means that cures will heal for +25% effective HP also. Example: PLD with 4000 HP takes 80% damage so effectively he has 5000 HP. A PLD who gets cured from 3000 > 4000 HP is effectively getting cured from 3750 > 5000. So a cure worth 1000 is effectively curing for 1250 ie. a 25% boost to healing.

Now there is a 10% bonus for PLD -> 80 HP, but the Warrior happended to use Storm's Path lol + 80 HP

So you admit that there is a 10% bonus to PLD.....and 25%-10% = 15% which just so happens to be the bonus applied to Defiance with Wrath V. So yes....PLD has an innate 25% bonus to healing.

[Judge_Xero]

Yes, but there in lies the problem. -20% damage taken is equivalent to a +25% to effective HP. But because your visible HP isn't actually going up this means that cures will heal for +25% effective HP also. Example: PLD with 4000 HP takes 80% damage so effectively he has 5000 HP. A PLD who gets cured from 3000 > 4000 HP is effectively getting cured from 3750 > 5000. So a cure worth 1000 is effectively curing for 1250 ie. a 25% boost to healing.

What's interesting about that is this end of it too.

4000 HP -> takes a 1000 hit which is reduced to 800
3200 HP -> Healed for 1000

now at 4000 HP (-20% effective heal)

So essentially there was no bonus.
-------------------------------------
Even if the heal was for 800

War - @ 4000 HP - Healed -> 4920 HP
PLD - @ 3200 HP - Healed -> 4000 HP

Now there is a 10% bonus for PLD -> 80 HP, but the Warrior happended to use Storm's Path lol + 80 HP

Probably worst case scenario would be if PLD and WAR had the same size HP Pool (example 2k heal)

6000 HP PLD - Takes 5k Damage - now @ 2k - 4k after heal
6000 HP WAR - Takes 5k damage - now @ 1k - 3.3k after heal

Just under 30% in favor of PLD