Is the water that bad?

[toshimoog]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUgw3cfEGfE

2. What don't people like about the water? It looks fine to me.. it moves.. has waves.. is semi-transparent and is reflective.... that's water, right?

The water itself looks REALLY nice, but there's one small disappointing thing:
The reflections are completely false. Square Enix seems to have faked the reflections and they don't reflect what's actually above the water. It is a false texture to make it "look like" you are seeing reflections; it is an illusion!

It's not so BAD, but I would have thought that making real reflections would be reasonable.