Why so adamant on keeping the Market Place?

[AngryNixon]

because they want to be different and don't want to be WoWish

I hope you're joking. If you are, very funny. If not, stop with the "don't want to be like WoW" argument, it's a dead horse. Adding an AH =/= WoW or "WoWish". Chicken Little always thinks the sky is falling.

And to the "they're the same thing right now" people or the "they're on par" people. No, they aren't. Maybe some distant day they will be, but not today.

@Mack: They will never understand. Flying spaghetti monster bless you for your patience though.