Indeed. It seems you are proficiently wielding the wrong end of my stick!
I mean by server, as in by world, as in have a list of the 10 worlds...
... and for all posters from a given world, totalling up the number of 'likes' those posts have.
No, that would be ridiculous! Whereas my suggestion is merely pointless, extremely hard to collate/maintain and returns nothing but to state that the now defunct Sargatanas server wins!
I'd apologise for wasting your time, but it seems you've got a lot to spare.
Keep up the good work!