Better Materia System

[Jynx]

have the exact same over all effect. RNG is not required.

I must disagree, taking all chance out of the system will make it extremly short lived no matter how time consuming you think it will be. People will eventually hit a platue and just crank the stuff out endlessly and eventually flood the market without the loss of gear and materia.

In such a system items are created but never removed from the game slowly building in supply (Or quickly as I assume) eventually leading to the death of the content itself being of importance for the average player to do so because veterans have crushed the market for it.

[Shougun]

I must disagree, taking all chance out of the system will make it extremly short lived no matter how time consuming you think it will be. People will eventually hit a platue and just crank the stuff out endlessly and eventually flood the market without the loss of gear and materia.

In such a system items are created but never removed from the game slowly building in supply (Or quickly as I assume) eventually leading to the death of the content itself being of importance for the average player to do so because veterans have crushed the market for it.

Content being outdated is natural, that is why the game will have to introduce new content at interval.

The materia rate from I to IV would be much slower in my suggested system - but I do see if no new materia tier was added for a long time then that top tier would slowly grow common (which doesn't mean the content is dead, but rather the difficulty of the content is dead lol - people would still use them).

Of course a simple change to the system to remedy would to just make it so you can't remove slotted materia unless it is a U/U materia. (If it gets out of hand, because I already suggested a minor counterweight to that. Where you have to destroy the item or pay a fee to get the materia removed - which would obviously increase based on number of materia and level of item/materia)

Threads need a time-out date for inactivity. Even I don't necropost my ideas, I just link them.

I'm unaware that I cant update my own posts when I want to talk about that particular previously made topic.