which weapon?

[Velhart]

Looking at pure stats, the Attack Power bonus makes the Flame Lieutenant superior to Garuda's Beak. If, however, your gear is focused on crit hits, the Garuda's Beak is better since you get +45 Crit Attack Power

Are there tests to prove this? STR/PIE gear vs. Crit Gear. If Crit Gear is proven better, I made a set for that also.