Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 409

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    Inversed situation or current situation, there shouldn't be a situation at all where they change tanks so fundamentally over a decade in. Paladin's and Bastion's will of course not mind the change, they get to keep playing Hero.

    It clearly doesn't affect your main, so it's easy for you take SE's side, innit?
    What about the tanks are they changing so fundamentally? We know both MT/OT are capable of being the one taking the hits, ie. the one infront of the boss and they even stated that the distinction will only really apply in Savage/Ultimate content (I don't think they added Extremes to the list, but I'm not going to check). SO the question that should be asked is, what is it about those encounters that means it would be more beneficial to bring both an MT and OT over, say 2 MT or 2 OT. Again, they have said the content would be clearable if you have the same style tank, you just might need to change how you approach certain things. Take from that what you want.

    Off the top of my head, the only real change to a boss encounter I can think of where the distinction would matter is if there was a period of time where the tank tanking a high amount of damage. the MT will be able to deal with it better, and whilst an OT can as well, they might need more babysitting from a healer.

    So, what is the actual issue that is making players say, oh no, my main is OT, quitting tanking forever, when we know nothing about what the change actually means other than the vague snippets of info we have got. Or, is it purely just the name that irks people?
    (1)

  2. #2
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    What about the tanks are they changing so fundamentally? We know both MT/OT are capable of being the one taking the hits, ie. the one infront of the boss and they even stated that the distinction will only really apply in Savage/Ultimate content (I don't think they added Extremes to the list, but I'm not going to check). SO the question that should be asked is, what is it about those encounters that means it would be more beneficial to bring both an MT and OT over, say 2 MT or 2 OT. Again, they have said the content would be clearable if you have the same style tank, you just might need to change how you approach certain things. Take from that what you want.

    Off the top of my head, the only real change to a boss encounter I can think of where the distinction would matter is if there was a period of time where the tank tanking a high amount of damage. the MT will be able to deal with it better, and whilst an OT can as well, they might need more babysitting from a healer.

    So, what is the actual issue that is making players say, oh no, my main is OT, quitting tanking forever, when we know nothing about what the change actually means other than the vague snippets of info we have got. Or, is it purely just the name that irks people?
    There will be a new mechanic requiring a mt and ot in savage and ultimate difficulty. You are forced to bring either bastion or paladin. Takes away flexibility and player choice.
    No idea what that mech will be. Maybe just plainly a tb that needs to be countered or something. Ideally it will end up not mattering and you can play whatever tank comp you want and the mt ot thing is just labels. I remember back in hw the devs wanted pld to mt anfd it was just bad and pld never got played. I don't trust them forcing a tank dplit again. And hell, i'm not even maining tank and am worried a lot about this. What if they do that nonsense splitting dps into support and big damage dps?
    Then again i could see them do that now that there are no buffs left in the game. How could you validate dnc dealing as much damage as a sam for example?
    (0)
    Last edited by Kishin12345; 09-07-2026 at 09:43 AM.

  3. #3
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    You are forced to bring either bastion or paladin. Takes away flexibility and player choice.
    You are also forced to bring tanks and healers in the first place, that takes away quite a lot more player choice and flexibility. And yet we don't see endless threads about that.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    What if they do that nonsense splitting dps into support and big damage dps?
    Uuuh, yes please? That'd be awesome! Whole reason I like Dancer is because it's an at least somewhat-support-ish DPS. Red Mage too, in certain scenarios. That's cool! That's variety! Give me more of that please.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    Then again i could see them do that now that there are no buffs left in the game. How could you validate dnc dealing as much damage as a sam for example?
    Dancer gets to keep their buff to a single person? The core spect stays, you yourself deal X less DPS, in return you pick someone else and buff them to deal X extra DPS -> same total damage, but in an indirect manner.

    And speaking of which, have you considered that that is how they'll balance "main" vs "off" tank? By damage? Because sadly, in FFXIV damage reigns 100% supreme even for non-damage classes. It's not like in other games where it is also important, it is the only relevant metric at all here.
    So, easy balance:
    * MTs deal 95% damage.
    * To get that missing 5%, they need to be actively attacked.
    * OTs deal 100% damage.
    * However, they lose 5% of that damage when they engage their active self-protection continuously.

    Done, MT/OT split entirely via damage. That'd be a terrible idea in any other MMO where tank balance relies on tank parameters, but it could be done here.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    Gunbreaker has an entire class identity I vibe with. My first FF game was VIII. It's not always about how a class plays to another. For some people it truly is about the lore of a class, the weapon used and other factors that have nothing to do with what you seem to value the most.
    Said lore doesn't actually say "Yo Gunbreakers, we are the main tanks", so such a person would be entirely unaffected by this change. To quote a great person, absolutely comparing oranges and apples here.
    (1)
    Last edited by Carighan; 09-07-2026 at 02:31 PM.

  4. #4
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    You are also forced to bring tanks and healers in the first place, that takes away quite a lot more player choice and flexibility. And yet we don't see endless threads about that.
    Absolutely comparing oranges and apples here. Desperate attempt or ignorance?

    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    Said lore doesn't actually say "Yo Gunbreakers, we are the main tanks", so such a person would be entirely unaffected by this change. To quote a great person, absolutely comparing oranges and apples here.
    Which is not the issue I have and why I decided to quit maining GNB as stated in a previous post of mine. You are arguing in bad faith so I am done replying to you.
    (1)
    Last edited by Pixieh; 09-07-2026 at 04:15 PM.

  5. #5
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    So, easy balance:
    * MTs deal 95% damage.
    * To get that missing 5%, they need to be actively attacked.
    * OTs deal 100% damage.
    * However, they lose 5% of that damage when they engage their active self-protection continuously.

    Done, MT/OT split entirely via damage. That'd be a terrible idea in any other MMO where tank balance relies on tank parameters, but it could be done here.
    You are suggesting punishing a job for using their own abilities. As a DRK I am actually kind of used to that... but I'd describe the experience more as "annoying" than "fun".

    If this is meant to be Savage difficulty and higher only, they said there will be new mechanics to leverage the new system and I hope they are more engaging and fun than "you used your mitigation too much, here is a damage down on you".

    If it's meant as general balance mechanic, for the OT it becomes a problem in all content when the OT might be required to actually tank, e.g. all dungeons, a fair number of Alliance raid encounters, all raid/trial roulettes when you are paired with another OT...

    For the MT will also be a problem in all content when they might get paired with another MT, e.g Alliance raids, raid/trial roulettes...

    So no, IMHO it's not a terrible idea "in any other MMO". It's a terrible idea period.
    (1)

  6. #6
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Mukuku View Post
    You are suggesting punishing a job for using their own abilities. As a DRK I am actually kind of used to that... but I'd describe the experience more as "annoying" than "fun".

    If this is meant to be Savage difficulty and higher only, they said there will be new mechanics to leverage the new system and I hope they are more engaging and fun than "you used your mitigation too much, here is a damage down on you".

    If it's meant as general balance mechanic, for the OT it becomes a problem in all content when the OT might be required to actually tank, e.g. all dungeons, a fair number of Alliance raid encounters, all raid/trial roulettes when you are paired with another OT...

    For the MT will also be a problem in all content when they might get paired with another MT, e.g Alliance raids, raid/trial roulettes...

    So no, IMHO it's not a terrible idea "in any other MMO". It's a terrible idea period.
    I absolutely agree.
    I would find that annoying, too
    A lot of these uniqueness stuff sounds way more annoying than fun overall.
    The healers in my group are pissed because SE is forcing them to gcd heal now!
    For so many years it has just been wrong to ever use a gcd heal.
    If you used a gcd heal you've been a bad healer. All was planned with ogcd healing.
    If i play drg i dont want to stall 5 seconds in the air. I want a trigger to instantly crash down on the opponent.
    As a drk i dont want to be degraded into an ot. I want to be able to step up and mt if the other tank struggles or is just a bad tank.
    I sincerely hope that the backlash is so huge that this tank split will be reverted in 9.0.
    Like in the japanese forums they are all doom and gloom about the whole evolved thing, tank split and especially the healer changes.
    I know that jp used to love the way healers have always played.
    I'm afraid we will have to bear with it for 8.0 though.
    (0)
    Last edited by Kishin12345; 09-07-2026 at 10:17 PM.

  7. #7
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    uuh, yes please? That'd be awesome! Whole reason I like Dancer is because it's an at least somewhat-support-ish DPS. Red Mage too, in certain scenarios. That's cool! That's variety! Give me more of that please.



    Dancer gets to keep their buff to a single person? The core spect stays, you yourself deal X less DPS, in return you pick someone else and buff them to deal X extra DPS -> same total damage, but in an indirect manner.

    And speaking of which, have you considered that that is how they'll balance "main" vs "off" tank? By damage? Because sadly, in FFXIV damage reigns 100% supreme even for non-damage classes. It's not like in other games where it is also important, it is the only relevant metric at all here.
    So, easy balance:
    * MTs deal 95% damage.
    * To get that missing 5%, they need to be actively attacked.
    * OTs deal 100% damage.
    * However, they lose 5% of that damage when they engage their active self-protection continuously.

    Done, MT/OT split entirely via damage. That'd be a terrible idea in any other MMO where tank balance relies on tank parameters, but it could be done here.



    Said lore doesn't actually say "Yo Gunbreakers, we are the main tanks", so such a person would be entirely unaffected by this change. To quote a great person, absolutely comparing oranges and apples here.
    I really hope that you are 100% wrong with everything you said. If dnc were to keep its buffs then that would mean that everyone needs ro sync their rotation to the dancer. The solo dance partner might still work, but will heavily favor some jobs over other jobs probably. More than it already does now.
    And if ot deals 100% and mt 95% of the damage then the choice is clear. Bring 2 ots. Already invalidates mt.
    Like you said in ffxiv you have to think in damage and not in utility.
    That is the way the game is played.
    It would be a problem if ast still has a dmg buff card. I dont think we will see anything like that anymore because of burst syncing.
    I suspect that ast will have a hard mit card, regen card and shield card if it even keeps its card system in the first place.
    The way i see identity or uniqueness is that it makes the job good or bad. So some jobs will inevitably be bad jobs and we know what happens when a job has low playrate.
    It will get changed so it fits in. What makes you think that will change?

    And yes we are forced to bring tanks and healers, but no one ever dared to dictate which tank you have to bring.
    The guy that mains drk since release and main tanked all ultimates and savages now gets degraded to ot.
    That hits hard. Players love their jobs for different reasons, you dont just switch jobs like their interchangeable at will.
    At the highest difficulty you feel allthe differences that tanks have. In thenormal roulette they might feel all the same but htey are not and never were.
    (1)
    Last edited by Kishin12345; 09-07-2026 at 10:41 PM.

  8. #8
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    And speaking of which, have you considered that that is how they'll balance "main" vs "off" tank? By damage? Because sadly, in FFXIV damage reigns 100% supreme even for non-damage classes. It's not like in other games where it is also important, it is the only relevant metric at all here.
    And well yes this is true. Which is another reason why i think that every job needs to deal about the same damage. If there were jobs that deal bad damage then you can play bad comps if you happen to find people that main the low dps jobs.
    In ultimates the dps checks are so tightly balanced that some comps could not meet them and besides the high dps jobs would just be the go to jobs then.
    If you kill the boss faster then the boss can't hurt you. So you won't need the support abilities of the low damage jobs. In a way high dps is the best mitigation we got in this game because simply skipping mechanics means you mitigated that mechanic's damage to 100%.
    So if they did split dps into support and burst dps then the support dps would just have either a very low playrate or not be played at all.
    Look at heavensward. You had to bring a certain comp for savage. It was like only 8 jobs existed.

    The "support" dps (phys ranged) takes longest to fill right now, too. It is just an undesirable role to fill in a game where everyone wants to be the star.
    Bard, as we've seen, has had its buff songs removed and the songs now do regen, shields and so on. No more damage buffs. Which makes me think all the more that there will be no buffs you can give to other players anymore. That would just require syncing damage again.
    (0)
    Last edited by Kishin12345; 09-07-2026 at 10:44 PM. Reason: Typos

  9. #9
    Player
    Lyth's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Location
    Meracydia
    Posts
    3,918
    Character
    Lythia Norvaine
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Beastmaster Lv 50
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    So, easy balance:
    * MTs deal 95% damage.
    * To get that missing 5%, they need to be actively attacked.
    * OTs deal 100% damage.
    * However, they lose 5% of that damage when they engage their active self-protection continuously.
    If players saw this on release, they'd just lock out main tanks entirely and run two off-tanks on swaps/invulns. If the off tanks take more damage as a result, then the expectation will be that the healers will sort it out.

    I'm reminded of Stormblood's tank accessory fiasco. The dev team wanted tanks to stop using STR accessories, so they role locked the new accessories and made them VIT only (such that tank accessories didn't provide meaningful damage progression). Tanks went back to the previous expansion's STR accessories (i270) and used them instead, while making their healers cross-compensate for the loss of eHP. They backtracked pretty much immediately.

    That being said, I would be surprised if counters make up a large portion of main tank damage, because the devs are averse to penalizing players for rotational mistakes (such as missing counters or not planning for them). But even a small dps imbalance between the subroles can be enough for players to start enforcing double main tank or double off tank setups, if there's not enough of a difference between the subroles outside of that.

    I think that if you want this role split to work, it needs to be through mitigation/utility. If a particular job provides a simpler way of solving a mechanic, then you'll still want to take that job regardless of small dps variations between jobs. Give players a reason to want to run one of each subrole, rather than trying to force them to play this way.
    (2)

  10. #10
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    So, what is the actual issue that is making players say, oh no, my main is OT, quitting tanking forever, when we know nothing about what the change actually means
    Like I said before. It does NOT matter what the change actually means because at the end of the day, the vast majority of the playerbase will only see the labels. They won't care about the details. They will see Main Tank and Off Tank and judge tanks by that. It really is that simple.
    (1)

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast