Page 31 of 41 FirstFirst ... 21 29 30 31 32 33 ... LastLast
Results 301 to 310 of 407
  1. #301
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,696
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Rithy255 View Post
    Specialized is at least a term that just doesn't hold any weight in current ff14. No Tank is different enough.
    ... Yes? The point? Exactly?

    But fun thing: How come Warriors being better at MTing (it's not just their invuln CD) is somehow not relevant, but somehow the new changes are going to be? We only know of the PLD, but nothing about their kit seems to suggest a meaningful specialization into main-tanking. And we already have non-meaningful elements that should in theory give us a preference, and many of us ignore it and just MT or OT or whatever. So we have no reason to assume this'd be any different, right?
    (0)
    Last edited by Carighan; 08-05-2026 at 11:12 PM.

  2. #302
    Player
    Rithy255's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2022
    Posts
    2,179
    Character
    Rithris Amaya
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    ... Yes? The point? Exactly?
    You said "we currently already have classes that specialize in MT or OT" which implies that theirs a significant difference in what tank is better at MT or OT
    (1)

  3. #303
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,696
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Rithy255 View Post
    You said "we currently already have classes that specialize in MT or OT" which implies that theirs a significant difference in what tank is better at MT or OT
    I didn't say "significant". My entire point is that nothing, absolutely nothing this dev team has done in the entire history of this game gives us any reason to assume the new MT/OT split would be significant, either. Hence why I absolutely don't understand the fearmongering.

    Would it be amazing if tanks actually specialized? Yes! Albeit not into MT/OT, but a per-tank specialization where each tank has its unique up- and downsides. The community would instantly implode if that happened, probably physically. Like you could see it on earthquake meters. You'd feel the ground tremble as everyone's head popped at the idea that there are situations they are worse at because of their class choice. Class.... matters!
    But it'd be really healthy so the tanks no longer feel like carbon-copies of each other. But I have exactly 0 hope this'll happen, as nothing they have done before suggests they are willing or able or funded to do this.
    (0)
    Last edited by Carighan; 08-05-2026 at 11:18 PM.

  4. #304
    Player
    Rithy255's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2022
    Posts
    2,179
    Character
    Rithris Amaya
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    I didn't say "significant". My entire point is that nothing, absolutely nothing this dev team has done in the entire history of this game gives us any reason to assume the new MT/OT split would be significant, either.
    I mean the pure and barrier healer split is pretty significant you usually dont want double pure healer, double barrier can be better in some situations.
    (2)

  5. #305
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,696
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Rithy255 View Post
    I mean the pure and barrier healer split is pretty significant you usually dont want double pure healer, double barrier can be better in some situations.
    That is true, but contrast that with the DPS subroles where despite being so significant in theory, absolutely nothing about them matters in actual gameplay as the fights are designed to account for the fact that some DPS are only able to work from melee range, and hence ensure that these players are never penalized for their choice of class.

    Meanwhile, the healer "split" you mean didn't split the healers, it formalized an existing design difference. Yes, they didn't actually remove the difference, in fact they embraces it instead. Before that we had one regen healer, one shield healer (those two weren't as strongly defined maybe as now) and one that could switch to either but was only really good at one of them if we're being honest. They formalized this, making the third a regen healer and adding another shield healer.

    But, contrast this with the tanks: There is no difference of any meaningful impact they could formalize, they'd first have to invent one. Meanwhile on the DPS side, do you really think they'd make being melee or caster meaningful again as in, you lose significant amounts of damage to being at range respectively moving, but if you can stay at melee range or can stand still you easily out-DPS others? I don't see that happening. And now consider that there is an existing specialization they could formalize there, at least remnants of one. And if they won't even do it there, imagine the extra steps of first adding a conceptual specialization, then formalizing it into four existing classes.

    Nah. Not happening.

    What we've seen so far seems to suggest MT means "I got a move that procs from being hit, but if need be I can also let someone else be hit in case I'm actually the OT". That doesn't sound like specialization to me, sorry.
    (0)

  6. #306
    Player
    Carstien's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2013
    Posts
    365
    Character
    Richter Cade
    World
    Alpha
    Main Class
    Gladiator Lv 100
    It probably matters pretty little. Unless they force it by adding an extra 1% buff for having an OT and an MT instead of just a buff cos you have a tank, you're free to play whatever anyway and if they did that, they would have to do it for the healers too. That would feel pretty forced but I wouldn't hate it tbh. I like defined roles though, I know that is not for everybody.

    I will wait until we have actual concrete information before I decide whether the split has meaning but overall I am in favour of the split in general.
    (1)

  7. #307
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    It's fascinating that to date no MMO dev has truly understood the "damage trumps all"-thing and tried to work on that directly. You'd think that since they can work on so many underlying issues no matter how much damage it causes to combat concepts, how much it removes class uniqueness or interesting class concepts, they could at some point fix the actual illnesses instead of just the symptoms?
    Is it an illness, or, just an inevitable consequence? As long as you have the tools to be able to survive everything a boss does, what else is there to optimise? Damage. Even in a situation where a fight releases that you need to grind out more gear for before you are able to beat it, you are still just working towards the tools to be able to survive. You can even get a bit abstract in that DPS is also a measure of survival as any DPS check needs that minimum level of damage in order to clear it. Even when getting more and more gear, your survivability goes up due to more health and healing, leaving larger margins, and on the flip side, the more damage you can do, the larger the margin you have to be sub-optimal in damage to clear.

    Of course, I can only really think of two approaches, and both would, naturally, be crass. In particular because they would completely upend the way MMORPGs work in our minds:
    And, in my opinion, both are heavily flawed.

    Removal of all visible numbers. No potencies listed in tooltips (only 5 keywords, "marginal", "small", "average", "large" and "huge", as in, "restoring a huge amount of health to the target and a marginal amount of health to all friendly target in a small radius"), no damage shown either taken or dealt, no numbers of health bars, no nothing. Server never reports damage either, only updates health % every so often, and in return the client reports which skills were used, so no datamining the numbers either.
    Cannot optimize with a near-total lack of information.
    For bonus points, open world enemies and target dummies now have a random damage resistance that keeps changing through the fight, -20% to +20% damage taken. Likewise, skills have a huuuuge damage variance, -50% to +50%, again with no reliable pattern.
    Then the system turns into press skill that says it does the most damage when you have buff up. Which is no different to what we have now. All you are doing is obfuscating the numbers to make them harder to get, but it still isn't impossible to extract numbers, even in the system you proposed. With enough data points on the same dummy, you will be able to take an average if the % to the dummy done (this can be done just by making the target HP bar as big as possible and count how many pixels were lost in the attack), do that with every skill. From there, just choose a skill to be the 'baseline' and then the damage of everything else is just presented as relative to that one action. From there, you can then create a rotation. Is it a lot more work? yes, but it is still very much possible.

    However,. what does this actually achieve? It is still the same system we have now, big potency goes into damage buffs, but you remove any sort of weird optimisations that could be done, not to mention, for some players, seeing that massive critical hit damage number is just a good dopamine hit. Even action games that do not show numbers, still have a responsive HP bar, so you know how much you have done. Setting up that big damage moment just to see a massive chunk taken out of the HP bar is a good feeling. It all just seems like a way to make doing damage, boring.

    Alternatively, normalize damage. On the fly. Essentially so long as you're "actively attacking", you produce X DPS output, no matter what. And X is balanced by the target you're attacking + your role, not the actual damage you're dealing. This'd not be perfect, in fact you could differe slightly, but the system would in-realtime push values together. Deal more damage, your next few skills magically fall on the lower end of the damage variance, and vice versa.
    This'd be even wilder. As long as you roughly press the right buttons, the game would force your damage to be equivalent to anybody else of the same role pressing, again, roughly the right buttons. It'd work, and in the end it's how tanking and healing are already balancing in games tbh, so it only makes sense to apply the same to damage. But it'd sure feel absolutely wild.
    In the end though, maybe WoW actually kinda does this already? It uses fudged PPM systems for many procs, and in a lot of ways these are exactly that, the game tries to push you to get the right number of procs per minute, basically.
    And this is even worse as, what is the point in trying? Just spamming your level 1 skill and you do as much damage as someone putting in the effort? And what is meant by 'roughly press the right buttons'? How much can you deviate before potentially ruining everything? What if, for a certain mechanic, it would be better to change things from this pre-programmed rotation to do more damage, but you get punished for it? Must do this, otherwise take a penalty.

    Regardless, though, how are these fixing the problems of 'damage trumps all'? Damage is still a relevant factor in how fights play out, so you haven't changed anything, just made it harder to optimise and build differing rotations.
    (0)

  8. #308
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    I never really post in this forum, I haven't read any replies but I just want to say, I hate what they'll be doing to tanks.

    As a gunbreaker main this is entirely killing my drive to even play the game anymore. I do not suffer from main character syndrome, I don't want nor need to main tank raids all the time but when I want to, I CAN and it's nice to have the spotlight at times to successfully main tank a raid. This change will make it impossible for gunbreakers, dark knights and warriors to EVER feel that amazing dopamine rush.

    I can only speak for myself, but I personally do not like playing Paladin. I think the weapons for Bastion look stupid as heck on all female characters, on male elezen, male viera and lala's. I don't care how fun that tank class might be, it won't fit my male Viera look wise and that kills it for me completely. Not to mention I am 1000000000% happy with Gunbreaker as my main.

    This tank split is completely sh*t design and I will die on that hill.
    (1)

  9. #309
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,696
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    As a gunbreaker main this is entirely killing my drive to even play the game anymore. I do not suffer from main character syndrome, I don't want nor need to main tank raids all the time but when I want to, I CAN and it's nice to have the spotlight at times to successfully main tank a raid. This change will make it impossible for gunbreakers, dark knights and warriors to EVER feel that amazing dopamine rush.
    We currently do not have indication that you will in any case, shape or form be prevented from or find it impossible to get the dopamine rush of main tanking as a Gunbreaker.

    You might, judging from current tooltips, deal marginally less damage as a whole raid group, and even that is not quite clear since we lack:

    * A true way of knowing whether and if yes how PLD mechanics (or BST) work when not being the main tank.
    * Knowledge how offtanks will work, mechanically.
    * Information about what "offtank's thing" will be.
    * Verification that BST shares the counter-hit mechanism we saw on PLD, and hence this is actually "main tank's thing".

    We do however currently have reason to assume that offtanks will still be plenty tanky enough to maintank any even savage-mode raid boss, since we know the current 4 tanks are of different levels of squishiness in dungeons + they can all tank savage bosses easily. Meaning if that they make DRK/GNB/WAR squishy enough to not tank raidbosses, then excluding massive game mechanics changes that'd probably invalidate Reborn Mode we'd see at least two of those three tanks be unable to tank any 4man dungeon any more. And they did confirm they want them to tank those just as well as PLD/BST.
    (0)
    Last edited by Carighan; 08-07-2026 at 06:48 PM.

  10. #310
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    We currently do not have indication that you will in any case, shape or form be prevented from or find it impossible to get the dopamine rush of main tanking as a Gunbreaker.
    Then why is SE splitting tanks into main tanks and off tanks? And why is gunbreaker officially lumped into the off tank category? Shouldn't that by default rule it out as a main tank?
    (1)

Page 31 of 41 FirstFirst ... 21 29 30 31 32 33 ... LastLast