Page 7 of 11 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 ... LastLast
Results 61 to 70 of 105
  1. #61
    Player
    Valence's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2018
    Posts
    6,047
    Character
    Sunie Mochi
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by BigCheez View Post
    Is anticheat really that invasive though?

    It isn't like you'd have an SE employee rooting through your filesystem. It would just be checking if there was anything interfering with the game and would be a huge net gain IMO.

    Personally, I would love if we could have achievements without the assumption that they were botted and WF races without the assumption that all teams are cheating.
    - Genshin Impact shipped with a kernel-mode anti-cheat driver signed with a legitimate Windows code-signing certificate. Attackers discovered they could reuse that signed driver outside the game to gain kernel privileges on victim machines. Ransomware operators and other malware authors began bundling the driver with their malware, even on computers that had never installed Genshin Impact, because Windows trusted the valid signature. The driver could then be abused to disable antivirus software and execute privileged operations.

    - Riot Games (League of Legends / Valorant): In 2023, Riot's development environment was compromised and the source code for its legacy anti-cheat was stolen. There was no compromise of Riot's code-signing certificates, but the source leak potentially helped cheat developers.

    - Capcom (2020): A vulnerability in Capcom's kernel anti-cheat driver allowed arbitrary kernel code loading on machines where it was installed. Capcom quickly removed the offending driver after public criticism.

    - Microsoft driver-signing abuse: Separate from gaming, Microsoft has documented cases where attackers obtained legitimately signed drivers (or fraudulently submitted drivers for signing) to gain kernel access.

    - ESEA where the company itself tried to insert a program using your GPU to mine bitcoin in the background. Granted, that one didn't need kernel access for this, they just abused their client base, but it was still an anti cheat.

    After those companies scandals, do you really trust CBU3 or SE with that kind of bomb? Imagine those stalking plugins but with ring0 access that they managed to crack.

    Other concern: it's like the "you don't have to worry if you haven't violated the law" cop excuse. Well all should know better.
    And finally, I appreciate that Yoshida seemed to share that sentiment about privacy.

    Anybody serious in computer security knows that allowing kernel access to third parties isn't exactly something healthy.
    (19)
    Last edited by Valence; 07-19-2026 at 05:43 PM.
    Secretly had a crush on Mao

  2. #62
    Player
    Aidorouge's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2024
    Posts
    638
    Character
    Buzam Aidorouge
    World
    Excalibur
    Main Class
    Ninja Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Valence View Post
    Other concern: it's like the "you don't have to worry if you haven't violated the law" cop excuse. Well all should know better.

    Anybody serious in computer security knows that allowing kernel access to third parties isn't exactly something healthy.
    Re-quoted and blown up for emphasis because it apparently needs to be hammered into some people's heads that most of us here speaking out against anti-cheat are not just a bunch of modbeast ERPers or hardcore raiders with dots clutching our pearls, we're simply people with a lick of goddamn common sense, ESPECIALLY when it comes to Square-Enix's track record so far of just flagrantly allowing anyone to access information they shouldn't have.

    An anti-cheat from SE would be endangering us MORE and the only benefit would be... *checks notes* ...slightly less FF14-related NSFW images on social media and the sanctity of world races I don't even watch? I shouldn't have to explain what a terrible trade-off that is, and I would rather have the gooners that I can't see what they're doing or saying anyway or tryhards I don't play with than whatever roaches crawl out of a hole to try and exploit root-access to my machine either for profit or lulz.

    And the craziest thing? We don't even need an anti-cheat to deal with all of the stalker mods, we simply need Square-Enix to not cheap out and vibe code a part of their own damn client. They can literally fix the problem right now by just rolling up their sleeves and paying attention this time, but some people here would rather they drop a nuke and well you know what they say about roaches surviving and thriving from that kind of thing.

    It would be a different story if Square-Enix had an impeccable reputation for coding and security, to where one might believe they could legitimately make an iron-clad anti-cheat that protected us all while doing away with third-party tools while implementing the most useful and ToS-friendly ones into the game themselves ...but we all know otherwise. Just look at their blacklist, or their speech bubbles, or their raid plans, see for yourself the complete and total half-assery. Now I want all of the people so gung-ho about an SE-certified anti-cheat to look at me with a straight face and tell me "trust them, bro, they got this".
    (10)

  3. #63
    Player
    BigCheez's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2021
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    1,065
    Character
    Cheez Whiz
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Valence View Post
    -
    So Genshin is still the only noteable example of anticheat actually having negative consequences for anyone, and we're just to ignore all of the positive examples of well-implemented ring 0 anticheat, or anticheat that works fairly effectively without kernal level access then?

    Quote Originally Posted by Aidorouge View Post
    An anti-cheat from SE would be endangering us MORE and the only benefit would be... *checks notes* ...slightly less FF14-related NSFW images on social media and the sanctity of world races I don't even watch? I shouldn't have to explain what a terrible trade-off that is, and I would rather have the gooners that I can't see what they're doing or saying anyway or tryhards I don't play with than whatever roaches crawl out of a hole to try and exploit root-access to my machine either for profit or lulz.
    It isn't only about gooner mods or the 0.1% who participate in the race for world's first. FFXIV's relationship with 3rd party software more generally is becoming incredibly unhealthy and it seems that it will just keep getting worse.

    Cheating is becoming increasingly common in PVP. Botting is getting out of hand. People are botting crafting/gathering/achievements for hours/days on end. Using bots to level their characters via duty support instead of engaging with roulettes and filling queues. There was a player on my server botting FATEs for about 2 weeks straight and SE didn't seem to care despite multiple reports. I just checked their Lodestone and they unlocked all of the "complete x duties" achievements for all 4 tanks within the space of the last week, lmao. Every time I form a static or fill for a friend who is missing a member for the week, I find out someone is either using triggers for TTS callouts for mechanics or the plugin that draws untelegraphed AOEs and suddenly they can't raid on patch days.

    The game is just becoming a clown fiesta and I don't like it. Plugins in FFXIV are now more impactful than they ever were in WoW and people used to clown on WoW endlessly for its playerbase not being able to play without them. This garbage would get you a permaban in WoW because they have anticheat to enforce a modicum of integrity in the game, and their addons can only interact with whatever Blizzard intentionally surfaces for them via their API.
    (1)
    Last edited by BigCheez; 07-20-2026 at 08:26 PM.

  4. #64
    Player
    Rein_eon_Osborne's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2020
    Location
    Shadowflare - Ward Miasma II, Plot Broil IV
    Posts
    4,362
    Character
    Mira Clearweaver
    World
    Jenova
    Main Class
    Conjurer Lv 90
    PvP cheats are kinda mixed bag in a way that most kind of cheatings happening there could be observed with naked eyes, but it's baffling how it's still that hard to get any actions at all. That sort of pointing toward lack of live moderation, if any at all.
    (1)

  5. #65
    Player
    Bubert's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2025
    Location
    Uldah
    Posts
    305
    Character
    Sugar Minuet
    World
    Raiden
    Main Class
    Pictomancer Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by BigCheez View Post
    The game is just becoming a clown fiesta and I don't like it. Plugins in FFXIV are now more impactful than they ever were in WoW and people used to clown on WoW endlessly for its playerbase not being able to play without them. This garbage would get you a permaban in WoW because they have anticheat to enforce a modicum of integrity in the game, and their addons can only interact with whatever Blizzard intentionally surfaces for them via their API.
    The difference is that Wow has a normal optimised launcher for other platforms than just Windows and SE doesn’t! They add anti cheat they will not only lose roleplayers, erpers, but also people who use quality plugins to make their gameplay easier due to disabilities or w.e and will also yeet Mac and Linux player base into oblivion because the game on the SE’s launcher is unplayable for them. Who’s gonna refund all these people?
    (3)

  6. #66
    Player
    BigCheez's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2021
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    1,065
    Character
    Cheez Whiz
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Bubert View Post
    The difference is that Wow has a normal optimised launcher for other platforms than just Windows and SE doesn’t! They add anti cheat they will not only lose roleplayers, erpers, but also people who use quality plugins to make their gameplay easier due to disabilities or w.e and will also yeet Mac and Linux player base into oblivion because the game on the SE’s launcher is unplayable for them. Who’s gonna refund all these people?
    The game had a better (and more healthy) RP community before gooner mods and venue cringe.

    Why would they refund people who chose to use illicit tools to play on unsupported platforms?
    (5)

  7. #67
    Player
    Kaurhz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Posts
    4,159
    Character
    Asuka Kirai
    World
    Sagittarius
    Main Class
    Dancer Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by BigCheez View Post
    So Genshin is still the only noteable example of anticheat actually having negative consequences for anyone, and we're just to ignore all of the positive examples of well-implemented ring 0 anticheat, or anticheat that works fairly effectively without kernal level access then?
    IMO, this partly misses the point as you're conflating lack of well-known exploits, with general system security, risk and vulnerability. Even of those that haven't been exploited, many of them still have their own associated CVEs, EAC had a vulnerability where it had an unquoted service path, which if exploited would allow code to be ran from system (This had a CVSS score of 8.4). BattlEye also had a CVE for unquoted service path (CVSS of 7.8) GFAC, a lesser known anti-cheat had several vulnerabilities associated with it (2 of which had a CVSS score of 7.8). PunkBuster also had quite a few for directory pathing (Way back when).

    Setting this aside though, many games with successful and good anti-cheats, also largely owe success to actually having a good moderation system in place. Since you would still find plenty of people bypassing these through various measures. Anti-cheats on a user-level are also much lesser known now, simply because they were much more easily bypassed, hence why we have kernal-mode now. You mostly only find these in single-player games.

    I sympathize with your point on modding and third-party software, but SE just has too many flags for it to really be practical. They need to moderate better, and they need to trust the client less than what they currently do so, before they should consider anti-cheat (Then there's competence to question)
    (4)

  8. #68
    Player
    Bubert's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2025
    Location
    Uldah
    Posts
    305
    Character
    Sugar Minuet
    World
    Raiden
    Main Class
    Pictomancer Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by BigCheez View Post
    The game had a better (and more healthy) RP community before gooner mods and venue cringe.

    Why would they refund people who chose to use illicit tools to play on unsupported platforms?
    Why are they selling their game for other platforms then?
    (3)

  9. #69
    Player
    Aidorouge's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2024
    Posts
    638
    Character
    Buzam Aidorouge
    World
    Excalibur
    Main Class
    Ninja Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by BigCheez View Post
    It isn't only about gooner mods or the 0.1% who participate in the race for world's first. FFXIV's relationship with 3rd party software more generally is becoming incredibly unhealthy and it seems that it will just keep getting worse.

    Cheating is becoming increasingly common in PVP. Botting is getting out of hand. People are botting crafting/gathering/achievements for hours/days on end. Using bots to level their characters via duty support instead of engaging with roulettes and filling queues. There was a player on my server botting FATEs for about 2 weeks straight and SE didn't seem to care despite multiple reports. I just checked their Lodestone and they unlocked all of the "complete x duties" achievements for all 4 tanks within the space of the last week, lmao. Every time I form a static or fill for a friend who is missing a member for the week, I find out someone is either using triggers for TTS callouts for mechanics or the plugin that draws untelegraphed AOEs and suddenly they can't raid on patch days.

    The game is just becoming a clown fiesta and I don't like it. Plugins in FFXIV are now more impactful than they ever were in WoW and people used to clown on WoW endlessly for its playerbase not being able to play without them. This garbage would get you a permaban in WoW because they have anticheat to enforce a modicum of integrity in the game, and their addons can only interact with whatever Blizzard intentionally surfaces for them via their API.
    I'm aware there's other mods that cause problems, though ironically, many of the pro-anti-cheat crowd always tunnel-visions onto gooner mods only for some reason, giving the impression they're okay with other kinds of mods. But when you remember how many people live and breathe by ACT... suddenly it makes sense why "my mods good, other mods bad" or why that same crowd then does mental gymnastics to explain why the game should have a built-in DPS meter (despite the fact that ACT has done more social damage to the game than Mare could ever dream of).

    But at least some of this still comes down to Square-Enix's own incompetence. They are completely and totally unwilling to have "in-game" GMs (which makes you wonder what the "G" even stands for) that monitor PVP matches and known PVE farming locations in real-time to snipe rule-breakers on sight. Square-Enix themselves are the ones who created asinine achievements requiring people to perform some dull task thousands (and sometimes TENS of thousands) of times including the "much praised" carrot one they added recently. The community in this game is frankly full of jerks so I don't blame people for preferring the NPC options (though they shouldn't be using methods to automate it, they're designed to be slow for a reason). The lack of action against people who get repeatedly reported once again falls on Square-Enix's head for failing to dole out punishments to obvious cheaters and bots. Hell, we can't even effectively report people like we can with RMT shouters. No right-click and send, we have to go through a ticket like a status report, right down to giving them exact time of day and location, implying they'll "get around to it" instead of having someone already on standby. And believe you me, I'll always be one of the first people to have a good laugh at raiders who "suddenly" can't raid on patch day (or several days after) but are right and ready once "certain programs" have been updated, and then have the gall to whine about casuals acting "entitled and lazy" even as they sit there in a bib and high-chair.

    I assume WoW's anti-cheat works as well as it does because they actually, you know, put effort into it and because they have an understanding of plugins in general after years of not only allowing them, but studying them. Meanwhile with Square-Enix, I get the feeling they only kinda glance at how mods work and then try to replicate them with mixed results, all while fighting against their own spaghetti code. As well, WoW GMs are the kind of ones people sit around telling spooky campfire stories about (or at least they did back in my day pre-Warlords), while we only get reminded that FF14 GMs exist at all when a forum topic suddenly disappears. At least half the reason that modding is rampant in FF14 is because there's literally no fear response from the community, they only get disappointed finger-wagging (from Yoshi-P himself no less), and sure enough we get some absolutely brat behavior including billboards and websites that tout and even taunt about what kind of mods are at work. That "dating" app and all of the stalker mods were not made by people with any fear of consequence, they were made by people who know the rod was not only spared, but broken over a knee and thrown away a long time ago.

    We'd have far more people thinking twice about mod-use if the repercussions for getting caught were immediate and frequent, instead of what we have right now where anyone and everyone can use them where it might take months, AT BEST, before someone finally gets smacked.
    (8)

  10. #70
    Player
    TeresaFortell's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2024
    Location
    Limnsa
    Posts
    709
    Character
    Metra Surrik
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Bubert View Post
    They add anti cheat they will not only lose roleplayers, erpers, but also people who use quality plugins to make their gameplay easier due to disabilities or w.e and will also yeet Mac and Linux player base into oblivion because the game on the SE’s launcher is unplayable for them. Who’s gonna refund all these people?
    The biggest offenders would be the people botting in game, because they could effectively ruin markets in game.
    (0)

Page 7 of 11 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 ... LastLast

Tags for this Thread