Results 1 to 10 of 409

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mukuku View Post
    The consequence of that is that "OT" tanks will find much less opportunities to "main tank" and vice-versa, which you seem to agree it's going to be by design. I find such design concerning.
    Why?

    Or rather, I should say, is that a universal concern?

    If yes: Does that mean you don't enjoy any current DPS that isn't PRanged, and also don't enjoy neither healer? And also, how do you square having that concern with the fact that the game clearly seems to be healthy despite the same split also being long-applied to those roles?
    If no: Why not? How come this is universally only a problem for tanks, despite both other roles showing that this does not blow up the role or its balancing?
    (1)

  2. #2
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    Or rather, I should say, is that a universal concern?
    It's actually universal. I don't think the game should move even more toward fixed sub-roles.

    In general I don't like the "you should bring 1 of each" design philosophy, because it effectively means telling the player "bring the job needed, not necessarily the job you might prefer to play".

    While there is always going to be some structure vs. flexibility, IMHO the devs' design should focus on "bring the job you prefer to play, we will make sure it will do great". A 2T/2H/4D comp would have structure but more flexibility than a 1MT-1OT/1PH-1BH/2MD-1CD-1RD comp.

    I also believe it's used as way to cover for balance issues for the individual jobs instead of properly addressing them. If parties would e.g not want a physical ranged DPS and would rather have another melee instead, the issue is in the jobs' balance.

    Said that, again, a lot of this is speculation. Maybe they will show OT and clarify further what they want to achieve and a lot of opinions will change, mine included.
    (4)

  3. #3
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mukuku View Post
    In general I don't like the "you should bring 1 of each" design philosophy, because it effectively means telling the player "bring the job needed, not necessarily the job you might prefer to play".

    While there is always going to be some structure vs. flexibility, IMHO the devs' design should focus on "bring the job you prefer to play, we will make sure it will do great". A 2T/2H/4D comp would have structure but more flexibility than a 1MT-1OT/1PH-1BH/2MD-1CD-1RD comp.
    That's a fair take, and I apologize. Universally applied that's a solid idea. I kinda like that conceptually too, I will however say that from... ouff, by now nearly 30 years of playing MMORPGs ( :scream: ), I more think it won't work, at least not... not truly.

    I mean hell, even GW2 kinda has roles, and that's a game that intentionally wanted to remove them all. But imbalances always exist, and it feels silly to pretend that "proper" balance can actually exist. If it could, someone would have managed by now. But nobody ever did. And while providing sub-roles isn't how I'd work with imbalance (I prefer unique class up- and downsides but people hate those even more usually as they mean singular specific classes are best for any individual encounter, and worst for other specific ones, too, but I like it as it allows great asymmetry between classes), I can accept it as one way of working with it. In a game like FFXIV at least, where swapping to another class within the same base role (not sub role) is so trivial, and the choices are vast and levelling is so frictionless and gear is even shared between various classes.

    But yeah, fair opinion. Mine differs, but it makes sense that if you universally don't like sub-roles for that reason, then of course an MT/OT split is also not something you'd like. And from the perspective, I fully agree!
    (1)
    Last edited by Carighan; 05-14-2026 at 02:41 AM.

  4. #4
    Player
    Mukuku's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2026
    Posts
    63
    Character
    Mukuku Muku
    World
    Spriggan
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    That's a fair take, and I apologize. Universally applied that's a solid idea. I kinda like that conceptually too, I will however say that from... ouff, by now nearly 30 years of playing MMORPGs (:scream, I more think it won't work, at least not... not truly.
    There is no need to apologize. I also fully understand it's a very difficult concept to pull off if "unique" jobs are also a requirement.

    I actually believe it's a "cursed problem" in game design, meaning a problem which puts different fundamental game promises in conflict with each other. Such problems cannot be really "solved" cleanly, they can be only compromised around.
    (1)