Please Return Randomness to Astrologian's Card System

[Azurarok]

Also if anyone wants to try to work out 'which card is best' with the above values, your example party is WAR, DRK, AST, SGE, MNK, NIN, MCH, RDM, and the fight is a 100% uptime, pure single-target fight

taking a shot in the dark without giving it too deep of a thought, I don't expect it to be right

Balance: MCH during raid buffs, NIN during off-minute burst assuming MNK is doing double Lunar opener
Bole: Whoever is your MT at the time, ideally WAR using Thrill of Battle
Arrow: WAR? Surprisingly has the highest auto-attack strength of the group, just at a slower rate which doesn't matter. MCH may have higher crit/dh rates though.
Ewer: SGE
Spear: MNK, ideally with Riddle of Wind
Spire: RDM