DRK feels super squish in comparison to the other tanks

[Mesarthim]

No. Why would I go digging through other people's threads for an answer you shouldve posted in THIS thread. Yeah you're a waste of time to talk to.

"I want this taken away from Living Dead but if you want to know what "I" want done with it here go read this unspecified thread made by someone else".

Comical.

[The_User]

Ah finally, someone who act like he can't be bothered to read but want to find fault in me no matter what.


"I wanted to bash this person but "I" can't be bothered to go read this referred thread that has the detail and explanation".

Comical.

[Mesarthim]

What are you, 5? Even edited your post to be a smartass too by repeating something.

[The_User]

Are you? because those edited line came from what you have edited. But by all mean, carry on with your personal insult. It show what is to be expected from you.

[Mesarthim]

"This message is hidden because The_User is on your ignore list.
View Post
Remove user from ignore list"

[The_User]

Adios, Thank for a useless banter.

[Mikey_R]

Oh wait, didn't we just compared ToB will TBN the other day? the nonsensical has already begun.

Yes, they were compared of which I specified that, whilst at a basic level you can treat them both like 'effective HP', there are other things to consider than could mean one provides a better benefit than the other. Ultimately, nothing to do with ToB and TBN, just the differences between shields and max HP increase.

You then came back saying that there was a 5% difference, completely missing the point that was being made in my posts.

[The_User]

Yes, they were compared of which I specified that, whilst at a basic level you can treat them both like 'effective HP', there are other things to consider than could mean one provides a better benefit than the other. Ultimately, nothing to do with ToB and TBN, just the differences between shields and max HP increase.

You then came back saying that there was a 5% difference, completely missing the point that was being made in my posts.

Yes and no. Just reducing them both down to effective HP does not tell the full story. TBN directly reduces the incoming damage whereas ToB does not. This difference is going to matter in some cases so it is important to not conflate the two.



Due to the nature of the two actions, one will be better than the other based on the incoming damage proportional to the tanks HP and how that damage is done. If it is damage done in the first 4 seconds, they are about even in terms of mitigating damage (not counting the BW healing), however, if some of the damage is done outside of that first 4 seconds, or if the shield is broken early, TBN is likely to mitigate more, again, not counting the healing. If you want to do some calcs yourself, I worked out that 400 potency heal on Warrior is about 7% of their max HP in healing (I checked with all my gear on and with no gear on except weapon, both came out to the same).

Are you sure? You did say how it is different.

[Grimforth]

Ah finally, someone who act like he can't be bothered to read

You're really in no position to be saying that. You got called out for being an idiot. And now you're trying to act like you know what you're talking about when you don't. And when you losing the argument, you start blocking people.

[The_User]

You're really in no position to be saying that. You got called out for being an idiot. And now you're trying to act like you know what you're talking about when you don't. And when you losing the argument, you start blocking people.

*Pfffffff*