Quote Originally Posted by Supersnow845 View Post
It’s not really so simple. For example nobody here can come to a consensus on how to nerf it. People seem to broadly agree on two points

1) it needs a nerf
2) don’t change it’s gameplay identity

Which presents a problem as PCT’s gameplay identity is why it’s unbalanced. So how would you do a nerf in this case. What are you aiming for with a nerf. Are you aiming for ultimate balance. What level of savage balance is worth ultimate balance and vice versa
Not having a consensus within the community is no excuse to keep things as they are. First, we are not professionals being paid to balance the DPS jobs. We can only give suggestions, and of course these will always be different, coming from people without any experience in developing games. Second, we don't know if there's a consensus within the development team.

There is no excuse to release an Ultimate with a job performing almost 10% above the average melee DPS. Patches are longer now. The reason for getting no PCT nerfs or a rework before FRU was given by them multiple times, and it's not difficulty or lack of consensus. They think the job will become unpopular, so they choose to release a broken Savage tier and Ultimate, instead of fixing game balance. Meanwhile, PCT is so popular that we have 30+ PCT FRU clears for every SMN clear.