Wow, Wuk Lamat is really single-handedly ruining the DT story...

[Raven2014]

you think you want another stormblood, but you dont.

Your point being?

If you tell me my choice is between SB and DT, I'll give you my answer even before you finish asking the question. And it won't be DT. I don't think trashing on SB helps DT's defense in any way. Because the lower you try to put down SB, it doesn't change the fact DT is a tier or two below that.

Even if the story is bad, SB at least has a cast that I found interesting while at the same time, I can't say I care for a single character in DT.

[MoiraTerrwell]

Your point being?

If you tell me my choice is between SB and DT, I'll give you my answer even before you finish asking the question. And it won't be DT. I don't think trashing on SB helps DT's defense in any way. Because the lower you try to put down SB, it doesn't change the fact DT is a tier or two below that.

Even if the story is bad, SB at least has a cast that I found interesting while at the same time, I can't say I care for a single character in DT.

What, not even Erenville?
Or are you specifically talking of characters we got to meet in Dawntrail.
I wanna learn about Koana, who he is when he's not around Wuk Lamat. I think that about sums up who I'm interested in in Dawntrail specific new characters.

[Raven2014]

What, not even Erenville?
Or are you specifically talking of characters we got to meet in Dawntrail.
I wanna learn about Koana, who he is when he's not around Wuk Lamat. I think that about sums up who I'm interested in in Dawntrail specific new characters.

Yes, not even Erenville. I think the attention he got wasn't because he's good, but because he's the least bad among a sea of terrible casts. It's not hard to look reasonable when standing next to someone like Wuk Lamat and a bunch of forgettable characters. But comparing to the like of Gogetsu, Yutsuyu and Hien, Erenville is a few leagues behind. Heck, I don't think he's even compared with secondary NPC like the Ruby sea or Azem NPCs. Also on a few occasion he overwrites the players with the "the WOL said no but they actually mean yes" writing, saying I'm not a fan of that is a polite understatement.


Koana from the beginning has been written as a nothing but a stepping stone for Wuk, his story progression at best doesn't make sense, and atrocious at worst. He's a plain character with the one single most noticeable trait is being a certified siscon. They're all mean to be the "devotee" type of NPC, but comparing Koana to the like of Gogetsu or Yugiri I don't think even make sense. If Gogetsu is an SSR devotee, Koana is like a generic upgrade fodder.