Enmity Management, Do we want it back?

[Chajii]

In any content where poor enmity management would actually be a problem, greeding a GCD can easily wipe the party.

First thing first, in situations such as bosses in dungeons, a player greeding only costs a healing resource from the healer, the boss turning around could lead to multiple players dying from it.

Telling them to leave the boss earlier is definitely easier than telling them to use Elusive Jump on cooldown as an example. Don't forget that if they weren't using their tools properly, then you would also have to explain to them why and how, which for the greed you can simply say "there is mechanic, stop doing your rotation and get to where you have to be"

[BigCheez]

First thing first, in situations such as bosses in dungeons, a player greeding only costs a healing resource from the healer, the boss turning around could lead to multiple players dying from it.

Telling them to leave the boss earlier is definitely easier than telling them to use Elusive Jump on cooldown as an example. Don't forget that if they weren't using their tools properly, then you would also have to explain to them why and how, which for the greed you can simply say "there is mechanic, stop doing your rotation and get to where you have to be"

Which dungeon boss could kill multiple players by turning around? They don't cleave and do basically no damage outside of being hit by mechanics. Absolute worst case scenario, a DPS manages to pull threat right before a tankbuster; but they can live it comfortably if they press their personals.

If a player isn't capable of pressing a button on cooldown, they aren't going to do enough damage to rip aggro. Your argument doesn't make sense.