You pull you tank question.

[Thurmnmurmn]

snip

1) The difference is that the act of pulling more is not against the TOS. The act of pulling more AFTER someone expresses they don't want big pulls is.

2) That's fair. My example here falls more in MPK then.
But the main point there was more at the end about how there still needs to be some communication before you can accuse an extra pull to fall under this. It's not just "you pull extra, it's reportable".

3) By this logic, any wipe could be reportable.

4) As I've pointed out in a previous post. The literal definition of a tank by SE is "Tank
High in HP and trained in defense, a tank serves as the party's shield. Skilled at keeping a foe's attention and bearing the brunt of enemy attacks."
Them keeping aggro is literally the job they are there for. What else would you consider as the bare minimum?

Overall communication is what determines most of these. All except the act of YPYT which is an outright refusal to play their role.