If you could, what order would you set tanks in terms of damage?

[aodhan_ofinnegain]

personally there is no reason tanks shouldn't be equal across the board save Crit / DH variance. People should be able to bring the tank they want to play in all setting and shouldn't be a hinderance like it was this expansion for PLD and WAR in the first 2 tiers. considering how close the tanks were in terms of damage in ShB, the devs really screwed up the balance massively this expansion, when all they had to do was build upon what they already had so close to perfect.

If I am completely honest at the beginning of the expac, in terms of complexity in rotations, Paladin should have been the furthest ahead in DPS compared to the other tanks, due to the amount of effort required to even attempt to stay on par with the other tanks, all the while the other tanks were practically doing the same thing during each burst window ad nauseam, but now that tanks are basically all the same across the board in difficulty to optimise, there is no reason for disparity.

[GoatOfWar]

personally there is no reason tanks shouldn't be equal across the board save Crit / DH variance. People should be able to bring the tank they want to play in all setting and shouldn't be a hinderance like it was this expansion for PLD and WAR in the first 2 tiers. considering how close the tanks were in terms of damage in ShB, the devs really screwed up the balance massively this expansion, when all they had to do was build upon what they already had so close to perfect.

If I am completely honest at the beginning of the expac, in terms of complexity in rotations, Paladin should have been the furthest ahead in DPS compared to the other tanks, due to the amount of effort required to even attempt to stay on par with the other tanks, all the while the other tanks were practically doing the same thing during each burst window ad nauseam, but now that tanks are basically all the same across the board in difficulty to optimise, there is no reason for disparity.

Then you should advocate for the removal of all your utility and self healing to close the gap between the 4 tanks too.