Chocobo Racing should give Tomestones

[Astrahime]

No.

Mahjong should give MGP.

[Naraka]

No.

Why not?

[Astrahime]

Why not?

It's a level 1 Non-Combat duty. Both parts of what I said are why.

[Naraka]

It's a level 1 Non-Combat duty. Both parts of what I said are why.

Then make it Rank 300+ that gives Tomestone? Easy!
First Place gets 1 Poetic etc

[Astrahime]

Then make it Rank 300+ that gives Tomestone? Easy!
First Place gets 1 Poetic etc

That's not how this works.
1: It's a level 1 duty.
- This means that it's not going to give you poetics. Poetics are from level 50+ content and ARR Tribal Quests when done with a level 50+ job. Cope.
2: It's a non-combat duty.
- There is no non-combat content that gives you poetics. Wondrous Tails requires you to do 9 Combat Duties.
3: It's a Gold Saucer duty.
- These give you MGP and NOTHING ELSE.

[BRVV]

That's not how this works.
1: It's a level 1 duty.
- This means that it's not going to give you poetics. Poetics are from level 50+ content and ARR Tribal Quests when done with a level 50+ job. Cope.
2: It's a non-combat duty.
- There is no non-combat content that gives you poetics. Wondrous Tails requires you to do 9 Combat Duties.
3: It's a Gold Saucer duty.
- These give you MGP and NOTHING ELSE.

Let's never change anything ever! The trials are always a sidequest! Tanks and Healers have stances! TP is just part of the game - accept it!

[Astrahime]

Let's never change anything ever! The trials are always a sidequest! Tanks and Healers have stances! TP is just part of the game - accept it!

ok grandpa let's get you back to bed.
Also you forgot bow/gun casttimes, MNK/NIN's stances, and pet jank

In every single other MMO/RPG ever, the horse racing minigame doesn't give you experience or the game's main currency. It gives you currency relating to gambling.
Some MMOs/RPGs have fishing mechanics, and they often give EXP. We have fishing and it's its own job.
There is no logical reason to give people PvE rewards for doing minigames outside of the designated event where that happens since we have said event.