Wuk Lamat's Poor EN Voice Acting

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

I've been paying for almost 14 years and I thought she was fine. I don't think length of time as a paying customer matters when it comes to how feedback should be received lol.


Also, I can say that most of the "feedback" in the previous two threads was not genuine.


I'd like to point out that we've learned that Erenville grew up with her, and yet I haven't seen a single person complain about them having an Icelandic? accent while being from the new world. Not one person.

[Vyrerus]

I don't think length of time as a paying customer matters lol.

It's a shame you don't value your own time and money you've spent supporting your own, beloved hobby then. :/ weird flex, but ok.

Also, I don't think you can be a proper arbiter about what's genuine.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

It's a shame you don't value your own time and money you've spent supporting your own, beloved hobby then. :/ weird flex, but ok.

Also, I don't think you can be a proper arbiter about what's genuine.

It's interesting you say I don't value my time and money when I'm clearly still enjoying the game, so I'm still getting the value I wanted. When that stops, then I'll have something to say. I don't find any issues with Wuk Lamat's VA. I'd also like to point out that with all of the hate Alphinaud's voice got and still gets, I have yet to see anyone attack his VA.





And attacking the VA personally is very much not genuine feedback.

[Boblawblah]

I've been paying for almost 14 years and I thought she was fine. I don't think length of time as a paying customer matters lol.


Also, I can say that most of the "feedback" in the previous two threads was not genuine.


I'd like to point out that we've learned that Erenville grew up with her, and yet I haven't seen a single person complain about them having an Icelandic? accent while being from the new world. Not one person.

[AngaratoSvartberg]

I've been paying for almost 14 years and I thought she was fine. I don't think length of time as a paying customer matters when it comes to how feedback should be received lol.


Also, I can say that most of the "feedback" in the previous two threads was not genuine.


I'd like to point out that we've learned that Erenville grew up with her, and yet I haven't seen a single person complain about them having an Icelandic? accent while being from the new world. Not one person.

cause he actually fucking talks like that irl. its not a fake accent.

also can we stop with the stupid arguement that if you dont like her voice acting you're transphobic?
babying her and protecting her isnt being lgbt+ friendly, its pathetic savior complex.
just treat her like a normal person ffs, a proffesional, that can take feedback.
her fake accent was trash, and the direction and emotion was awful.
so was galool ja ja's. and wuk evu's and most of the side characters.

stop with the fake accents. if you want accents hire people with those accents like they did with radz-at-han in endwalker. they all sounded great

[Gilihere]

cause he actually fucking talks like that irl. its not a fake accent.

also can we stop with the stupid arguement that if you dont like her voice acting you're transphobic?
babying her and protecting her isnt being lgbt+ friendly, its pathetic savior complex.
just treat her like a normal person ffs, a proffesional, that can take feedback.
her fake accent was trash, and the direction and emotion was awful.
so was galool ja ja's. and wuk evu's and most of the side characters.

stop with the fake accents. if you want accents hire people with those accents like they did with radz-at-han in endwalker. they all sounded great

The statement in bold should say it all, it shouldn't matter who or what the person is being professional means that you are able to take criticism and improve

[Souljacker]

also can we stop with the stupid arguement that if you dont like her voice acting you're transphobic?
babying her and protecting her isnt being lgbt+ friendly, its pathetic savior complex.

I've been pretty active in these threads since before the launch, when we first got a taste of what was to come. No one accused anyone of being transphobic unless that poster had already for whatever reason thought it was worth bringing it into the conversation by mentioning this completely irrelevant topic. Folks were literally stalking her, curating and posting tweets YEARS DEEP from her feed. Name another VA that has EVER gotten that treatment here, regardless of how mediocre his or her performance was? It borders on obsession. It's sickening.

No, there's definitely something different about the way many folks have 'discussed' this particular VA, and the ones that argued in good faith were correctly engaged with in kind. It's very disingenuous to suggest that every single person who had a critical thing to say (of which I was certainly one) was immediately dismissed as phobic.