I'd be fine with SCH having dots and a return of bane, in fact I'd welcome that, it used to be enjoyable. I definitely would not want to see dots on AST For multiple reasons: there's no connection to the job as there is with SCH (job identity), if I have a job where I would be centered around tracking dots (SCH) - I don't want another one, and if I would prefer to have a mix of DPS skills (some of which could have time delays, macro comes to mind) and selecting/tracking buffs.

I hope that's comprehensible.