Quote Originally Posted by Jonnycbad View Post
My main point is that while yes, Dynamis is thinner here, it isn't absent. Therefore rather than 1 or 2 beings wishing fervently for water to return or to fly again and it happening fairly instantly, on Etheirys it may be it requires millions of people to hold a religious belief that animals gain sentience and power if they live long enough. Widespread, mass-scale belief over centuries could have a similar effect as what we witness in Thule, but the time required is much longer due to Dynamis being thinner. If it worked for the 12 and the 12 being shaped by peoples beliefs, why not for auspices. If people believe they have a wrathful form (aramitama) then that's what transpires, not unlike how when Dalamud was launched, suddenly the superstition that it was Menphina's hound manifested a pet dog in Menphina's realm.
I think I see how you're getting yourself confused: you're stretching the definition of dynamis. Dynamis is an emotional energy. Emotion is not the same as wishes, beliefs, or prayers. If you want to better understand the difference between these abstract concepts, dictionary definitions and wikipedia articles should get you moving in the right direction.

But all complexity about Dynamis aside, I think the biggest mistake you've made is to make the assumption that auspices are an unnatural phenomenon that needs explanation, rather than a natural part of the way life on Etheirys works. And that's a huuuuge assumption when we're talking about a fantasy world filled with magic and ghosts.