Quote Originally Posted by Ranaku View Post
Y'shtola feels like a self insert character of the story writers, like she merged with Ishikawa when she entered the aetherial sea and now we have this cat demigod that dies every expansion and already knows everything.

And i am mortified to know that she will be right there with us in Dawntrail cause we already saw her in the trailer. So it will be just another expansion of this story that slowly starts to feel rather like a fan-fiction than what it used to be in HW.
Might be in a minority here, but I can't stand Y'shtola. I'd take being an entire expansion with Urianger speaking in old English with riddles than having to be with the Scion whose only personality traits are "I like sweets" and "Hah got cha' I'm so smart and snarky".

If she wasn't a Miqo'Te I bet all my Gil her fan base would be smaller. Since she's the flagship Catgirl she gets immediate attention, despite the being plenty of more attractive and interesting Catgirls in the game. I'm surprised that thread didn't get down voted to oblivion since the subreddit is like the Church of Y'shtola.