Dawntrail Wishlist top 3 desired healer additions

[Renathras]

Okay, to put it a different way - I'm not trying to be antagonistic - is this an answer to the first question that allows multiple choices or the second that wants you to pick just one?

As a survey taker instead of the maker, I read them as "Which things would you like to see" and "OF THOSE THINGS, which do you want the most to happen?", which are different questions. For example, maybe a lot of people (probably a majority) want to see ability upgrades, but that isn't the thing they most want to happen.

I was just asking if this was an answer to the first of those questions or the second.

I take it by your answer (which was...well...never mind) the second of those questions. Anyway, let's see...

What new actions or changes are you hoping to see:

WHM
New attacks 48(85.7%)
New Lily Actions 34(60.7%)
New Blood Lily Actions 28(50%) / Other forms of Utility 27(48.2%)

SCH
New Attacks 48(84.2%)
Faerie Gauge Changes 46(80.7%)
New Faerie Gauge Actions 37(64.9%)
[Next nearest is Aetherflow Gauge Changes at 31(54.4%)

AST
Arcana Gauge Changes 33(73.3%)
New Attacks 30(66.7%)
New Draw/Play Actions 29(64.4%)
[New Minor Arcana Actions 25(55.6%), New DPS Buffs and New Star Sign Actions both got 23(51.1%) and all other options got less than 50%, though Other forms of Utility close at 21(46.7%)]

SGE
New Attacks 45(882.%)
New Addersting Actions 36(70.6%)
New Eukrasian Gauge Actions 24(47.1%)
[New Addersting Actions was right behind at 23(45.1%)]

which is one the thing you are most interested:

WHM
New Attacks 37(66.1%)
New Group Mitigation 6(10.7%)
New Lily Actions 5(8.9%)
[Upgrades to Existing Actions and New Blood Lily actions both got 2(3.6%), everything else just 1]

SCH
New Attacks 35(61.4%)
Faerie Gauge Changes 7(12.3%)
New Faerie Gauge Actions 5(8.8%)
[Aetherflow Gauge Changes 4(7%) and New Healing/Barrier OGCD Abilities 2(3.5%), everything else just 1]

AST
New Attacks 13(28.9%)
New Draw/Play Actions 10(22.2%)
Arcana Gauge Changes 9(20%)
[New DPS Buffs at 5(11.1%) was the only other thing with more than 10%]

SGE
New Attacks 37(72.5%)
New Addersting Actions 5(9.8%)
[Upgrades to Existing Actions, Addersgall Change, and Unsure all got 2(3.9%), everything else just 1]

.

Given "New Attacks" was the lead for the second question for everyone (though in different percentages from AST's low of 28.9% to SGE's high of 72.5%, the first question shows a big of a more complex picture in terms of just things that people want more generally. I'm also curious how people interpreted "New Attacks" vs "New Blood Lily/Addersting Actions" (the latter of which would clearly be new attacks/DPS buttons, most likely, and yet...)

I agree with you on AST needing a card rework. I figured that was what "New Draw/Play Actions" was supposed to mean, though wasn't entirely sure, and I suppose Minor Arcana as a second question splits that a bit. New Minor Arcana ITSELF got over 50% in the first question.

EDIT:

Crap, forgot the averages: (prior results from https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...8Hk/edit#gid=0 in perenthesis) - Number of responses

WHM: 4.56 (4.67) - 55

SCH: 4.41 (5.18) - 56

AST: 3.36 (4.55) - 44

SGE: 4.66 (5.18) - 50

Where the prior results were SGE=SCH > WHM > AST (with the latter two being not far apart), now we see SGE > WHM > SCH >> AST, which has had the bottom fall out of it. WHM had the smallest change of -0.11, leading to it moving up to 2nd, AST the biggest, falling by -1.19, SGE by -0.52, SCH by -0.77 to 3rd.

This is still a small sample size, only 44 for AST and 56 on the high end for SCH, but it's still interesting.