When you deal with human beings, never count on logic or consistency.
Fluid like water. Smooth like silk. Pepperoni like pizza.
Please no.
I never played NieR so the NieR raids, while spectacles, were meaningless to me. They didn't tie the white powder into the Sin Eaters, they didn't do any connection between the worlds, nothing. It was a side story that apparently said something to NieR players, but had no ties in the FFXIV world and thus were meaningless to us here other than "Oh, we saved the world again...I think? Wasn't really clear on who we were fighting, why, if they were a threat, or what kind of threat they were, or even they even were at all. And what happened to the Dwarf at the end? Oh, right, he just left and we never hear from him again. Oh, what's that? That's just how Yoko Taro writes his stories? Well, guess I'm never playing any game he writes, then, because that sucks."
I'd much rather something like Ivalice which actually exists in FFXIV and is RELEVANT to the events in FFXIV and even later events (like the Bozja Resistance). Crystal Tower tied into FFXIV's history/lore with the Allegans and (even if you want to say it was a retcon later) into ShB, Shadows of Mhach again tied into the game's lore (5th Era) closed out the Diablos story from the Amdapor dungeons and arguably also foreshadowed the future (6.1-6.4), and Ivalice I already mentioned, but it build into more lore related to the world/map and Garlemald, and of course into the Bozjan Resistance and arguably the fall of Garlemald.
What did the NeiR raids play into?
LITERALLY nothing.
If they're going to do crossovers, they need to be relevant to FFXIV's world and players, not only people that played that other game.
Renathras
I did enjoy NieR, and looked at the actual game NieR Automata to sdee what all the fuss was about, had been released recently to see more...and this is where your hip pocket will scream.
$100 AUD
Yeah..Ill wait till the price drops...........
Speaking of crossovers with old SE games, you know what we need? A Parasite Eve crossover. They already dipped their toes into Resident Evil style bosses with Devil May Cry music.
(Why yes, I am indeed looking at you Lahabrea. However did you manage to puzzle that one out?)
We need a Super Mario bross crossover. Kan-E-Senna and some moogles gets kidnapped for Golbez into the Void, and we need to get into some raids, and at the end of the raids a single moogle appears saying "Sorry WoL but our princess is in another castle, kupo!"
Part of the issue is mostly how Yoko Taro does things. His stuff can be philosophical, depressing, and comedic at the same time. It doesn't mesh well with a game like this, especially since androids don't really work here. It COULD have worked if the Nier raids were this expansion and the locations were accessed in Ultima Thule, but not really how it was implemented.
Keep in mind also that Lea Monde COULD fit simply because the game itself is about a single lone operative in the middle ages trying to stop a cult and save the son of the kidnapped duke. He just ends up walking into a conspiracy at a location where the supernatural lies. Ghosts, demons, dark magic, forbidden spells and in the deepest depths a grimoire that holds magic so powerful it could easily destroy nations. This location is also where, in FF14, the IVth Legion had their base set up.
Imagine that a survivor from that Legion decided to get their hands on that grimoire to fulfill their own ambitions. Imagine if this was happening at the same time as a diplomatic summit with Bozja/Nagxia/Dalmasca that we were invited to as a bodyguard for the Eorzean Alliance's representatives.
Last edited by RyuDragnier; 05-03-2023 at 12:17 AM.
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.