Another day, another thinly veiled 'you think you know what is best for healers but actually it is I who knows best' thread

Quote Originally Posted by Renathras View Post
Alone among the Healers could current WHM be ported into 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, or 6.0 and work (and actually be an improvement over 4.X, 5.X, and 6.0 itself, and probably over 3.X and 2.X)
A DPS class that had a trait that said 'your autoattack potency is multiplied by 10' with no actual actions would 'work'. It'd also be boring beyond belief to play, if 'just autoattacking' can even be considered 'playing the game'. We don't talk about what 'works' or doesn't, because if it doesn't 'work' it doesn't even reach the live game. What we talk about is what is 'fun' to us, and every one of these threads you make that tries to tell us that you know what is best and we don't are getting tiresome. Yeh, current WHM would fit if it were backported to previous expansions. That doesn't tell me that WHM is good right now. It just tells me that however bad it is atm, it was worse before. It tells me that the improvements to Lilies made in SHB, and then again in EW, should have been how SB launched, and then SHB would have built upon THAT, and EW upon THAT, instead of the mad scramble to salvage

I thought we were getting somewhere, finding consensus on some things. Instead we're back to the adversarial vibes