My gripe on blue mage tanks

[Seraphor]

Placing yourself at the top of the enmity list, is not a way of initially pulling aggro.

You might have aggro for a split second, but the moment anyone else generates any enmity, you will lose aggro. This will occur within a split second as someone else's attack connects after your Frog Legs.

Frog Legs is a enmity catch up mechanic. If you're way behind on enmity and you need to be on top, you start with Frog Legs to put yourself on the same level as the highest enmity. But in order to gain an enmity lead, you need to use something that generates enmity, which Frog Legs doesn't do.

[geekgirl101]

Frog Legs is a enmity catch up mechanic. If you're way behind on enmity and you need to be on top, you start with Frog Legs to put yourself on the same level as the highest enmity. But in order to gain an enmity lead, you need to use something that generates enmity, which Frog Legs doesn't do.

That's not the way it's worded in the tooltip. The tooltip gives the impression that it behaves the same as provoke.

Just to double check are you sure your nearby the enemies? As frog legs has abysmal range that needs you to be basically hugging the boss to work.

Yes I was practically on top of them and they didn't respond at all to it.

[ICountFrom0]

Provoke got HUGE BUFFS so it not only puts you on top, it puts you on top and then adds 25%.

That's a buff to provoke that blu never got, so blu does exactly what it says on the tin, while provoke has hidden bonus that isn't written anywhere, and causes confusion by being secret.

[Renathras]

Provoke got HUGE BUFFS so it not only puts you on top, it puts you on top and then adds 25%.

That's a buff to provoke that blu never got, so blu does exactly what it says on the tin, while provoke has hidden bonus that isn't written anywhere, and causes confusion by being secret.

This.

Provoke USED to work this way where it put you even with the top enmity person, maybe +1 or something. So you immediately had to do your threat combo (back when Tanks had those) otherwise that person would immediately pull threat using their very next attack. Provoke now has an extra bonus on top of that, I think, but it didn't always, and Frog Legs is modeled after the old provoke.

The things you want are things like The Look or Sticky Tongue with the "Additional Effect: Increased Enmity" tag. Contrast "Increased Enmity" (which the normal Tanks' ranged thing like Shield Lob or Tomahawk also have) vs "placing yourself at the top". Increased Enmity are the things you spam in your rotation to maintain a threat lead, "placing yourself at the top" is what you use if you're already behind to catch up (e.g if you died and got raised or for a Tank swap) followed quickly by Increased Enmity abilities to ensure you STAY at the top and widen your threat lead.

EDIT: Oh, and White Wind. Because massive AOE overhealing generates huge threat. It's one reason the Hunt Train (when tons of people) meta is having a bunch of Healers on your team just tag the enemy then chain cast their AOE spells while one Tank in Tank stance spams their ranged agro generator ability. Mark rewards are based on party agro.

[Daeriion_Aeradiir]

That's not the way it's worded in the tooltip. The tooltip gives the impression that it behaves the same as provoke.

Frog legs works by taking the highest enmity in the party and adding +1 to it. Meaning you need to follow up with something very high enmity, such as white wind hitting multiple people.
Provoke used to work the same way, but as part of their enmity changes to make tanking easier, they changed voke to be top enmity + additional enmity on top equaling a 2000-ish potency skill, which is also affected by tank stance.

However, frog legs never got the updated buff, meaning its still clunky to use comparatively. But yes, when in doubt, throw a white wind or two as long as your HP isn't abyssmal at the time of the cast. White wind hitting multiple people can generate absurd levels of aggro.

[Seraphor]

That's not the way it's worded in the tooltip. The tooltip gives the impression that it behaves the same as provoke.

Yes, this is also exactly how Provoke works.
Provoke doesn't give you an enmity lead, or at least, it doesn't give you a significant enmity lead, you need to generate additional Enmity to make that happen.
A tank who just uses Provoke will have aggro pulled off them after a single attack from another player.

For example. If another play has 1000 enmity on a target, and you have 0. If you use Provoke your enmity is set (not increased by any amount, set to a specific value) to 1100 enmity, to give you a slight lead. But then that other player uses an attack that connects and generates 200 enmity, giving them 1200 enmity and putting them back in the lead.
While that Provoke technically gave you a whopping 1100 enmity in a single move, it's not a enmity generating move, it's an enmity setting move.

Frog legs works similarly, except it may not give as much of a lead as Provoke. While my Provoke example set your enmity to 100 more than the next highest player, Frog legs might only set your enmity to 1 more than the next highest player.

Edit: Provoke obvious received a buff to increase it's initial enmity lead, which BLU spells didn't get.