SCH shields are overwriting SGE shields

[TabrisOmbrelame]

That’s definitely new because a SGE using e prognosis used to be able to fully block a SCH from using any shield except catalyse which can’t be spread

This isn't new at all.

In fact, shield replacing one another was already a thing back to Shadowbringer when Astromancer could use the Nocturnal Stance (Shield Stance).

and the explanation is the exact same as my last post..

So after some more testing here is what happens :


Adlo can't replace E-Prognosis even if Adlo is stronger then E-prognosis.

E-Prognosis WILL REPLACE Adlo, no matter what the strengh of the shield is.

The critical effect of both shield can be cumulated on one target, resulting in an absurd amount of shield for one target. (Catalyze + Differential Diagnosis + E-Prognosis will basically make a shield around 540% of the heal done if the two healers got similar equipment, which is... yeah kinda overpowered but not exactly that usefull either.)


How shield should be working :

Adlo/E-prognosis would replace each other if the value of the shield exceed the first (For exemple, adlo make 5000, then Prognosis 6000, Prognosis will be the shield)

If a heal is critical, the same rules apply for the first shield (Not the special shield triggered by critical). Replacement of the shield must be done on final value alone and not base value.

The critical shield can still cumulate on any target because it's not specified that Catalyze and Differential Diagnosis can't apply to the same target.