It's time to revaluate paper crown battlementors

[Krotoan]

Good idea on the face, but if Twitter has proven anything, it's that it's all to easy for a group of like-minded players to cancel anyone they don't collectively like. All it would take is a slip about Trump, to use an obvious example, and you'd be out on a rail.

I'd say the amount of actions against you would probably border on getting permabanned. or have some sort of review available. Honestly is it any different than it is now with people saying that certain NN's are "out to get them"?

The whole point of being a mentor is just being available. Would any large group of people be that petty about not letting someone try to help? ... well yes... but any more than they can now?

I think the removal of any rewards or exclusivity would take away any sort of "prestige" people linked with it and you'd be more of an info booth sort of presence than being special.

[Shibi]

I think the removal of any rewards or exclusivity would take away any sort of "prestige" people linked with it and you'd be more of an info booth sort of presence than being special.

Yes, I do agree in removing rewards including the crown icon. Move the mount reward to something else without wiping people's progress towards it.

For the western audience, I don't think community policing can ever be a panacæa, especially in a full /mentor for all system.

As much as we'd likely all love it, it's not too difficult to see how it could be easy to troll without something as a gate to slow down the trolls. Completing SB and one of each RED/Green/Blue class might, might be enough of a bar for your /mentor for all suggestion. Maybe it would need more though.

Maybe only positive reinforcement from that point, with mentors and players tagging responses as helpful to help the mentor rise in rank. The rank allowing an increasing number of responses per hour. It's easy enough to stop a second account self-voting by adding a lower limit to the number of helpfull votes.