Quote Originally Posted by Recon1o6 View Post
i mean summoner is in a similar situation, remove carbuncle adn it breaks
Debatable since the Carbuncle is pretty much useless at this point and only has a purpose for the shield and raid buff it provides, both of which could be redesigned to function without the carbuncle. The reason removing ED breaks SCH is because of both Dissipation and the Fairy Guage. The Carbuncle could be completely phased out and not really impact SMN much at all whereas you'd need to redesign at least some small part of SCH's toolkit to do the same.