New MCH “Buffs” Are Insulting

[LilyPendragon]

This is why SE need to scrap it and start over again.. with proper identity DPS or support. Turning it to a "unga bunga" job with rework and abandoning it not a solution :3

I agree. pRanged should all be buffing/support DPS so we don't have MCH occupying the weird space it currently does.

Which job is complex?
There is no complex job, it's time to accept that.

If you think there's no difference between MCH (or DNC for that matter) complexity and MNK, BLM (or hell even Astro but that's a whole other mess) complexity I don't know what to tell ya. Am I saying any job in this game is particularly complex? Not really. I've played competitive Starcraft, I know complex and XIV ain't it. But to put MCH complexity as anywhere other than pretty much at the bottom of the pile in the DPS roles is ridiculous.

If complexity should be used in balancing, RPR would be bottom

And RPR is still ridiculously overpowered, even after yesterday's patch.

[CKNovel]

If you think there's no difference between MCH (or DNC for that matter) complexity and MNK, BLM (or hell even Astro but that's a whole other mess) complexity I don't know what to tell ya. Am I saying any job in this game is particularly complex? Not really. I've played competitive Starcraft, I know complex and XIV ain't it. But to put MCH complexity as anywhere other than pretty much at the bottom of the pile in the DPS roles is ridiculous.

MCH is not complex but I'm listening...

I never put MCH at the same level of complexity.
I just said that all jobs complexity is very low.

On a scale of complexity from 0 to 100, if SMN is 1, MCH is a 10, then BLM is no higher than a 15, maybe a 20 if you really want to push it.
There is a lot of jobs easier than MCH. RPR, SAM, DNC, RDM, SMN.
BRD and DRG are not far from MCH complexity either.
And this is why we can't balance around complexity, SAM would be below NIN, SMN would be unplayable.

Good on you for playing Starcraft but this is XIV forums.

[MagiusNecros]

Which job is complex?
There is no complex job, it's time to accept that.

This is correct. No job in the game is complex. The most complex jobs arguably should be crafters but every crafter will use macros anyway for perfect crafts everytime so complexity is thrown out the window.

When it comes to MCH it's a very braindead uunga buunga job. It was arguably more complex before the rework.

[ICountFrom0]

isn't the per second potency of flamethrower still stronger? But I guess the heat gain make scattergun better in the long run. Maybe make flamethrower gain heat since it is fire after all haha

Flamethrower stops autoattack.
The damage from autoattack plus the shotgun damage is higher than the flamethrower already.
Add in heat and .. yha, you fall way behind.