Quote Originally Posted by Lurina View Post
When you meet Elidibus in the Crystal Tower, his line is weird - he doesn't just say that he saw you in Elpis, he says, "I saw you... No, I did not. But I did." Like he's remembering two different versions of history at the same time.

So it's not impossible that Pandaemonium is already building to some kind of split timeline scenario in the way that the WoL's first visit - from which Venat and Emet seem to remember you uncomplicatedly - was not.
Could this not be a reference to how Elidibus is not really "Elidibus" due to his memories being intensely damaged? So he has memories of Elidibus seeing the WoL in Elpis, but it is not really "his" memories.