*Spoilers* Anyone feel joining Emet would have been better

[Rulakir]

That's an extremely wild reach to make.

It's funny you should say that since it's the closest I've come to agreeing with the other side of the debate. However, if you want to argue that all of the Ancients were good who didn't deserve their fate I'm here for it!

[MikkoAkure]

It's funny you should say that since it's the closest I've come to agreeing with the other side of the debate. However, if you want to argue that all of the Ancients were good who didn't deserve their fate I'm here for it!

I'm not sure how that counts as being the closest you've come to agreeing when that 25% of the people left that you're disparaging also includes the large chunk of people who summoned Hydaelyn.

I won't say that all the Ancients were good people, Hermes is a piece of work and Hesperos had some deep-seated feelings he was hiding that were drawn out and magnified by who-knows-what. But I don't believe there is anything in the text supporting the idea that a quarter of the Final Days survivors who made it to the summonings were bad or weak people.