Mentor Requirements

[Themarvin]

No thanks.

A lot of people grind scrips for materia and I'm not entirely sure just how well you understand how painful making thousands of scrip/collectible turn-ins is.

I did the amount needed by hand back then, it didn't take long, if 10x more times by hand, it would feel like reached a point, if I need additional scrips currently, I just craft or gather it out by hand depending on which type I am looking for, it is a bit tame that you got a couple of class types, that can be done all by auto.

[Kaurhz]

I did the amount needed by hand back then, it didn't take long, if 10x more times by hand, it would feel like reached a point, if I need additional scrips currently, I just craft or gather it out by hand depending on which type I am looking for, it is a bit tame that you got a couple of class types, that can be done all by auto.

Yes, and the point being it adds nothing of any reasonable value to both the experience of the player, and what would be the expected competencies of a mentor for crafters/gatherers. Whether you do them by hand, or whether you do them by the macro is almost entirely irrelevant because they are significantly under tuned recipes that don't teach anything, not to mention the simple fact of the matter if you want to establish some level of standards then there are far more productive ways of accomplishing the goal.

Inflating the number, be it from 1000 to 2000, to 3000, to 4000, or whatever arbitrary number you want to attach, all you accomplish is unnecessary tedium. Doesn't really make anyone a better mentor, versus making them branch out, but even then this is limited. Though if I were to be frank crafting/gathering mentors shouldn't even exist.

[Themarvin]

Yes, and the point being it adds nothing of any reasonable value to both the experience of the player, and what would be the expected competencies of a mentor for crafters/gatherers. Whether you do them by hand, or whether you do them by the macro is almost entirely irrelevant because they are significantly under tuned recipes that don't teach anything, not to mention the simple fact of the matter if you want to establish some level of standards then there are far more productive ways of accomplishing the goal.

Inflating the number, be it from 1000 to 2000, to 3000, to 4000, or whatever arbitrary number you want to attach, all you accomplish is unnecessary tedium. Doesn't really make anyone a better mentor, versus making them branch out, but even then this is limited. Though if I were to be frank crafting/gathering mentors shouldn't even exist.

How will you keep bad people out of novice network, that just did it, to be able to stay in novice network then or for some kind of status symbol?

It needs to be as hard to obtain as PvE variant is... as in right now you can just do it blindfolded with little to no effort at all.

[Kaurhz]

How will you keep bad people out of novice network, that just did it, to be able to stay in novice network then or for some kind of status symbol?

It needs to be as hard to obtain as PvE variant is... as in right now you can just do it blindfolded with little to no effort at all.

You don't. Crafting and Gathering both have several ways of achieving the same goal so it is very flexible in what it allows for in terms of advice, with the only differentiation being efficiency, which is largely tied to several other interdependencies, budget constraints (How much Gil the person has, What the economy is like at that given time), resources (what melds do they have?), what their goals are, and so forth. There is no right and wrong, there is no universal advice that you give to everyone. Do you want to spend Gil whilst you're level and get it done with relative speed? Do you want to make Gil as you level and go for it slower) Both of these can yield a wide range of advice. Combat on the other hand is very black and white.

None of these things, answers, and considerations into their circumstances are things that will be taught or established through unnecessarily increasing the collectible count, as it is always just retaining the same level of difficulty/quality with the only factor being changed is the goalpost. In fact, nothing within the confines of the game or the crafting system itself will sufficiently teach you how to be a good crafter or gatherer mentor. Hence why my mindset is either force people to branch out and delves into all aspects of the crafting and gathering system in order to obtain mentorship. Yes, that does include the artificially difficult 'Expert' recipes. Or simply put, mentorship for crafters/gatherers shouldn't exist otherwise. With preference being to the latter, honestly

Increasing collectible count just turns the whole mentorship into drones upon drones who only demonstrate experience or 'competence' within the confines of mindlessly grinding under tuned recipes.

You either have these qualities or you don't. In fact, I can find several people who are very well suited for giving advice, despite the fact they're still in the leveling process themselves, and considered a relative beginner, Case in point; LucidFaith. I can easily argue this reigns true for combat as well, really. Hence the meme BK crown.