Since we got an expansion announcement coming. The preasure to repeat Shadowbringers.

[Mansion]

shadowbringer just had a good story and art direction
but thats pretty much it
I would take another SB or HW over ShB

100% agree.
Just comparing ShB with HW which had an equally great story and less overall resources, but many more dungeons and content in general, it makes me think Shadowbringers isn't that great of an expansion in itself. The story doesn't make up for the lack of content.

[Absurdity]

100% agree.
Just comparing ShB with HW which had an equally great story and less overall resources, but many more dungeons and content in general, it makes me think Shadowbringers isn't that great of an expansion in itself. The story doesn't make up for the lack of content.

Shadowbringers was basically carried by it's launch. The story blew everyone away, especially with such a great villain. But if we take the story out of the equation and only look at the other content then I'd argue even Stormblood was at the very least equal to Shadowbringers.