Can we get the "fail" version of the new Starlight choir song as an orchestrion roll?

[AmemeAmeklin]

I did wonder about that after saying it's appropriate that the bass is not that skilled... I don't know enough about choir singing to recognise how "good" the singers are, but have they gone to the effort of making it sound like a professional tenor and a few nice-sounding amateurs?

The balance is off. Alto is hard to hear, soprano is steamrolling everyone else, bass is shy, tenor is really reaching for those notes...ahh, reminds me of high school choir again.

Here is an example of a well-balanced quartet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xgiSl-KibQ
If you want to hear amateur singers...I don't really like saying this because it feels uncharitable but basically just look for any American church quartet and you'll likely find a good example of amateur singing.

And just for fun, here's a duet for two cats (sung by a pair of boys...boys are cats, right?): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMdn0ezJxUE

[Iscah]

If you want to hear amateur singers...I don't really like saying this because it feels uncharitable but basically just look for any American church quartet and you'll likely find a good example of amateur singing.

Hah, I very nearly did suggest "church choir" as an example of good but amateur singers...

And your analysis of the different voices sounds like we can excuse it at being in-character, whether that was the intent or not!

[AmemeAmeklin]

Hah, I very nearly did suggest "church choir" as an example of good but amateur singers...

And your analysis of the different voices sounds like we can excuse it at being in-character, whether that was the intent or not!

Amateur for sure but it deeeeefinitely varies on the 'good' part.

And yes! I found it perfectly acceptable considering the story. Unfortunately I don't like listening to it because of my admittedly-distant music education which nevertheless informs my standards in music XD

[LastFireAce]

Yessss please give it to us!

[MsQi]

Anyone mind if I bring this back up? Has there ever been any official word on this?

[Vahlnir]

Uploaded a video of singing "out of tune"

https://youtu.be/JWYm3M9wdyA

That was beautiful. Absolutely beautiful. I need this playing in my house asap.

[Oichi]

Totally worth it. I crack up every single time I listen to fail versions, they are fantastic. Please, let us have orchestrion rolls with them

[Gula]

I'd put it on loop in all of my houses and no one could stop me.

[Tlamila]

Yes please! I love it way more than the "good" version.

[Vahlnir]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBwJZDVdLyY

I would like to request this year's version as well. It might be better than last year's, in my opinion.