I picked Faerie because it was the only non-preferred server where character creation was available on the night that I started playing.
I consciously chose to make a character on a non-preferred server because I didn't want the EXP boost; I enjoy being on the journey as much as arriving at the destination. Being a WoW refugee, I figured that if this game were anything like WoW then I was worried that I'd end up outlevelling the story if I had the exp boost (which wasn't unfounded -- I'm 7 levels ahead of the story quests without even doing sidequests or spamming dungeons).
I actually played in the v. 1.0 beta and hated it. I thought I'd never come back to it, but the latest expansion for WoW is really not good and I've been in denial for a while.. LOL. Last week I decided, on a whim, to buy the base game and give it another shot and I immediately felt like a fool for avoiding it so long.