Revelations from SHADOWBRINGERS

[Alleo]

Like i said we just have to wait and see what happens between 5.1 to 6.0.

There is a lot of things we know now that may be revealed to be a lie during these moments and what we believe is not possible maybe possible in the end.

There is a saying in Guild Wars 2 from the Priory Order being "History never lies but Historians do."

And good writers still dont just tell us that every single thing we know is a lie thus I still cant see how your theory can even happen. For this to happen we suddenly have to find a way to combine everything without death and somehow withouth consequences to the source and go against our character and let them act completely different.

Also Yoshida himself has pointed out that he is a very skeptic person and wants to hear both sides and warned people to just see Hydealyn suddenly as evil just because we got the Ascians side..that we should wait to hear her too. This still sounds to me that they are not planning to do whole turnarounds.

And I am not sure what Historians being subjective and not 100% accurate in their lore has to do with your examples on what could happen? Historians have no hand in that. Even if people suddenly all knew about the past what would that really change? Maybe you have some people like Varis that believes that they should be complete and perfect again but honestly I do believe that most people would be quite fine with living the way they are if it means living at all..And again why should people like the WoL or even the scions start to try to find a way to combine the worlds again? These shards are (without Ascians) seemingly completely fine on their own.

So my question again: Why should that even happen? Why should the writers of FF14 even go that way when they showed us that these people on the shards are just like us and that they are quite happy living. Why should they change it when they have used Alphinaud and the others to say that its fine to live like that because its their life and they have the right to live. What would be the purpose? To be suprising (and subverting expectations..) just for the sake of it?