In shadowbringers, picking a tank is taking whoever 2 people on whichever two classes you want.

Except for how their rotation works (warrior and dk have more defined burst phases, paladin and gunbreaker have 2 modes they cycle between), theres almost no difference. They specifically designed tanks around being interchangable.


Which leaves you with personal differences, which are pretty much all discernable in parses. Did you let your self buffs drop? Did you maximize burst phases? Did you press the button that says "this didnt kill me, try again shortly"? (If you didn't, your damage will be awful because you just died).

Tank success at everything else will be easily discernable by their damage output.