Auction House system to complement existing Market Areas (Discussion) [dev1019]

[kukurumei]

ok I'll say it one more time, they should use eq2's broker system, instead of in house msg boards we have retainers, basiclly work the same way, all retainers are located in the MW's, brokers are placed around the city and have a search function for all retainers in the world, the broker can both tell the player exactly where to find the retainer, Grid:crystal market etc. or for a small fee the player can buy the item directly from the broker and the broker just pulls it from the retainers inventory, this would appease the folks wanting an ah and those who like the inconvience of a mw

It still wouldn't work well because you are still going to overload the retainer/market ward system.

The retainer/market ward system scales very very badly and is incredibly slow and buggy. It still takes a load of time to actually buy and sell things, and in wards that are overcrowded, and prone to crashing.

A broker system wouldn't work because the foundation would crash and burn too often and can't keep up with the expected volume.

It's like running the NYSE on your dell laptop with windows on it. It just won't work the moment people actually buy and sell.

The retainer/market ward system is pure BS. It's built around the idea of small scale trading. No matter the bandaid, it'll buckle mightily fast the moment it gets into the big times.

Ironically with the subscription base of current FF14 on its last legs, we may never need to see the big picture.

The better idea would be to have both at the same time, a global AH with high tax rates, and a market ward with low tax rates or something to that effect.

Trying to mix retainers/market wards is a step into the destruction path, because it's graphically, physically, and server-wize highly demanding.

If an efficient age of trading like WoW that is so keen on efficiency it's even able to program custom filter, you would have thousands of trades an hour.

You'll get a stock market crash every time the wards crash, or someone recalls a retainer to do some inventorying.

[origamikitsune]

Trying to mix retainers/market wards is a step into the destruction path, because it's graphically, physically, and server-wize highly demanding.

And people standing around the Juno or Whitegate AH during peak time wasn't? They already had to separate the city zones into two servers because of lag. What do you think will happen if everyone starts congregating at the same spot to do all their sales/purchases? Give the market wards the right functionality, and it essentially becomes an AH. Fix the market wards instead of scrapping them because, frankly, there's isn't much difference between the two and if they can't fix the wards, what makes you think they can make an AH work without crashing?