Make gender locked items in Mog Station tradeable for their equivalent item

[Ranhansha]

Do you know if devs usually take notice of these threads? Is there anything else I could do? I fear 80 likes might not be enough for them to consider the idea

[Fhaerron]

Do you know if devs usually take notice of these threads? Is there anything else I could do? I fear 80 likes might not be enough for them to consider the idea

Learn Japanese and post on the Japanese forums.


We're just low class citizens on the english forum. They don't care about us.

[Ranhansha]

Learn Japanese and post on the Japanese forums.


We're just low class citizens on the english forum. They don't care about us.

I hope that is just sarcasm, otherwise it's really disheartening.

[Nanami_Naniwa]

As someone who switches gender time over time I highly support this. My inventory is stuffed with gear my character can't wear xD

[Ranhansha]

As someone who switches gender time over time I highly support this. My inventory is stuffed with gear my character can't wear xD

Thank you for supporting the petition

[Bixillarla]

I am female and play only female characters so have no issues but for those who do switch genders I support this idea. If you buy something from the mog station there should be a way to swap it for the opposite gender if it has a equvilent.

[Mimilu]

Learn Japanese and post on the Japanese forums.
We're just low class citizens on the english forum. They don't care about us.

I hope that is just sarcasm, otherwise it's really disheartening.

It's kind of half true... >x>
Everyone on the Dev team speaks Japanese but not all of them speak English or are fluent in it and we have no clue what the Community team takes from the forums and tells them.

[Ranhansha]

It's kind of half true... >x>
Everyone on the Dev team speaks Japanese but not all of them speak English or are fluent in it and we have no clue what the Community team takes from the forums and tells them.

I hope they have someone checking the concerns of people from other servers, especially with the release of Shadowbringers and the effort they put into its promotion, but you might be right. Which worries me.

[Shougun]

I hope they have someone checking the concerns of people from other servers, especially with the release of Shadowbringers and the effort they put into its promotion, but you might be right. Which worries me.

Long ago I asked how they do the forums, and iirc the response was along the lines of they translate quite a bit of what's being said and go over it and it takes a lot of their time. We've also heard a bit more recently that they take the top threads and read those.

On terms of if they do anything from what we say, I think so but it could just be coincidence that I ask for something that they already were going to do lol. But just picking a few examples:

Summoner used to not have demi. I had really wanted summoner to get bigger summons and I was constantly being stonewalled (lol) by people saying lore forbids it. At which point I started to write reasons it could work and had written A. what if the summoner collects aether in the air like a battery over the period of their attacks and then that allows them to temporarily go beyond the lore limitations by utilizing this battery (charge it up, then expend it). And B. in a different post said I bet there is loads of bahamut aether in the air. Now of course I could have just described a possible logical conclusion to players wanting something bigger, but we did happen to basically get a battery mechanic that uses our attacks and residual aether in the air and a bigger egi as a result of it.

Another random class example, I had wanted Paladin to get a protective skill that had wings emerge from his back and protect those behind him in a cone. A while later we have Passage of Arms.. I think I said it prevented knockbacks in the cone or something but I was still like mouth open "who do I have to hug for this?". Interestingly Yoshida said he was surprised when he saw one of the designers working on this concept just for fun and they convinced him to add it (paraphrasing), which means either feedback goes to the proper channels and perhaps not always through Yoshida (which makes sense, the dude would need to be a literal computer to be able to absorb all the forums all the time lol) or coincidence . Much weaker example being I (and a few others) had asked if Paladin could keep going down the holy route, and so it seems we are (earlier on Paladin was less magical/holy).

In 1.0->2.0 time (ARR almost entering closed beta) I made a post detailing a system that allowed you to manipulate the camera, emote animations, lights, and filters, so you could take pictures. The purpose being to celebrate the social aspect of the game and as well act as a great source of fan-advertising.

Probably more likely something to have happened naturally anyway but I had really disliked the 1.0 materia system that broke gear on failure, asked for loads of stuff that didn't get added (which is cool, never expect everything I want to be done because some of it is probably terrible lol). But notably materia slots were added to gear, including dungeon gear, gear no longer broke, and caps were added to prevent some of the silly stat stacking (things I asked for). In that thread I also detailed a system to craft advance materia in the basement of the FC as big community projects (many stages, group crafts), now of course again could be coincidence but the whole "miniature"/"workshop" felt really similar to what we see (although has nothing to do with materia).

Quite a few other small items I can think of (QoL/UI/etc) and it leaves me with a strong feeling that either I'm a broken clock right twice a day, a knockoff nostradamus lol, or they do find at least inspiration from the forums. Often changing things to fit the game and their own spirit, which is good I think- keeps the game theme'd together better and I'm sure make some better decisions lol. I want to key in that inspiration and perhaps encouragement aspect though (if they're getting ideas/inspiration from their community they're not taking random comments and being like "copy paste that exactly", they massage it to be better and more reaslitic to implement lol, as well to ensure the FFXIV spirit and spin stays in it).

Also I full well expect quite a few of what I think are possible inspirations are just coincidence but the above felt a bit unique to me since they were said long enough before implementation that a development cycle may have included them. At this point I've either fooled myself or I can confirm to you that they do indeed both read and take inspiration/design consideration from the forums (including English). Now I can't tell you if that's because some Community Manager is working day in and out at a frenzy pace to communicate what we're saying and Yoshida is reading every bit, or if a random dev that can read English just sometimes pops in for fun but.. I still strongly feel that we're listened to, at minimum at least sometimes.

[Barraind]

I hope that is just sarcasm, otherwise it's really disheartening.

Its squeenix. Its been that way since before they were the same company. They have long held, and stated publicly that your voice matters less if you arent Japanese. This was true in the NES days and is true in the current PC, mobile and card game days. If they have any say in it (and they retain those rights with every one of their IP's they farm out to third parties) you WILL have a better gameplay experience in the Japanese version.