They made it this way because in FFXI there was a huge problem of ppl getting pugs in a group and then kicking them before loot could drop. Funny enough it was mostly an issue on the jp side. It happened quite often that a jp group would bring English players in and then warp them out before they could claim loot.

And everyone would dismiss ppl for harassment then, even if it was just for kicks to get them a penalty. And the amount of manpower it would take to investigate each and every one kick wouldn't be worth it for a problem that is, frankly, small. If you are seeing a lot of toxic players than idk what is going on on your end, as someone who has been here since original launch, I would say toxicity is a small issue in this game compared to others. And find the ppl usually complaining about overwhelming toxicity to be either incredibly overly sensitive. esp for an online environment, or particularly toxic themselves and are just experiencing others players reactions to their toxicity.

So, no, this is not at all a good idea.