Results 1 to 10 of 177

Thread: SHADOWBRINGERS

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player Dualgunner's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2014
    Location
    Gridania
    Posts
    2,942
    Character
    Lilila Lila
    World
    Coeurl
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 80
    Quote Originally Posted by Melichoir View Post
    Again, its relative to how well the light is doing overall.

    Consider the current age: Weve been victorious against....

    Titan
    Garuda
    Ifrit
    Shiva
    Nidd
    Shinryu
    Garlemald on numerous occassions
    Dragon Space Pope
    Diablo (and all Raids connected to Him)
    Bismark
    Zurvan
    Ravana
    Sophia
    Sephirot
    Alaggan Junk
    Omega Weapon
    Lakshmi
    Ultima Weap
    Lahabrea and Ascian ilk broadly
    Wars of Darkness

    These are All victories for the light, so to speak.
    Victory for the Light: The Warrior of Light defeats their foe, no matter what that means for the grander scheme of things.
    Victory for Darkness: Causing an apocalyptic-level event that at best forces civilizations to adapt to permanently altered climates and casualties in staggering amounts, and at worst literally floods the entire world and wipes entire civilizations off the face of it. These calamities all signalling the end of an era and the merging of one shard into the primary one, which is something as far as I'm aware can't be undone--as opposed to all of the Light's victories so far.

    We killed Ifrit, for instance. But he can be re-summoned at a whim. I'd perhaps wipe every victory off that list except for permanently sealing away Igeyorhm and Nabreales, as well as Lahabrea being absorbed by Thordan. Even then, we stomp one and more appear.
    (2)

  2. #2
    Player
    Melichoir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Location
    Uldah
    Posts
    1,537
    Character
    Desia Demarseille
    World
    Sargatanas
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Dualgunner View Post
    Victory for the Light: The Warrior of Light defeats their foe, no matter what that means for the grander scheme of things.
    Victory for Darkness: Causing an apocalyptic-level event that at best forces civilizations to adapt to permanently altered climates and casualties in staggering amounts, and at worst literally floods the entire world and wipes entire civilizations off the face of it. These calamities all signalling the end of an era and the merging of one shard into the primary one, which is something as far as I'm aware can't be undone--as opposed to all of the Light's victories so far.

    We killed Ifrit, for instance. But he can be re-summoned at a whim. I'd perhaps wipe every victory off that list except for permanently sealing away Igeyorhm and Nabreales, as well as Lahabrea being absorbed by Thordan. Even then, we stomp one and more appear.
    I think your overselling the calamities. They caused prominent civilizations with a region to falter/collapse, but that doesnt always mean the absolute obliteration of everything, as we can see that we're all still here (so to speak) and knowledge and technology marches forward. Again, this is in relationship to how well the light is doing. I keep pointing that out because in the grander scheme of things, its Zodiark whos locked up, not Hydaelyn, when both are implied to be necessary for balance. And for Zodiark to have been locked up, what kind of battle was waged and on what scale to have that outcome. An outcome that is a clear and decisive victory for Hydaelyn, where all calamities, while thus far terrible, still havent spelled defeat or doom for Hydaelyn.

    A subtle note to my point is the WoL is either damage control, or operating on continuing the current status quo, where the Ascians are operating on ending the current status quo and returning it to the former one (however far back that is). For some ascians, its cause Zodiark is best god. But for others (Elidibus) its for returning things to the intended state. A sentiment that has implications that IF things continue uncontested for Hydaelyn, everything gets screwed. Just like what happened on the Warriors of Darkness homeworld.

    There are a lot of questions to actually think about. Like this for example:

    If Hydaelyn remains unchecked, the conclusion is the world gets enveloped by light and destroyed, as demonstrated on other worlds when one side of the spectrum gains to much power (Creatures from the void are from worlds that fell into darkness). So, in making sure things are kept in check, does that means the ascians and their actions are necessary evils?
    (0)

  3. #3
    Player
    kikix12's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Posts
    953
    Character
    Seraphitia Faro
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    Scholar Lv 80
    Quote Originally Posted by Melichoir View Post
    I think your overselling the calamities. They caused prominent civilizations with a region to falter/collapse, but that doesnt always mean the absolute obliteration of everything, as we can see that we're all still here (so to speak) and knowledge and technology marches forward.
    Technology vastly worse than what was several centuries (millenia?!) ago, magic vastly weaker than what was centuries (millenia?!) ago. And no, Garlemald doesn't count. They use ALLAGAN technology, as taught to them by Ascians. And even then they are inferior to actual Allagan still.

    White Mages, Black Mages, Scholars...all of these jobs were almost lost to time because of these calamities. Entire groups of people were lost to time, becoming nothing more than history that needs to be uncovered from old tomes.

    Sure...The calamities weren't a big deal and the light was doing just spiffy...

    Sorry, but it's like saying that The Black Death was a sneeze, World War I and II were just small arguments or that obliteration of one continent (whichever one) in real world would be no problem cause, hey, there are several more left, right!

    Quote Originally Posted by Melichoir View Post
    Again, this is in relationship to how well the light is doing. I keep pointing that out because in the grander scheme of things, its Zodiark whos locked up, not Hydaelyn, when both are implied to be necessary for balance.
    Yeah...Except the light is losing from the moment that Hydaelyn sealed Zodiark. I'm pretty sure that she said it herself, that Zodiark suddenly begun craving destruction or something like that and that she had to seal him. And also that it did cost her a lot of her energy. You know...Sealing is usually done against someone you CANNOT defeat in fiction. Point in question...how the Warring Triad was sealed, how Bahamut was sealed, how the big-bad from the Four Lords (I don't remember his name...) is sealed. All of them are more powerful than who they fought and that's why they were sealed in desperation and not defeated.

    Quote Originally Posted by Melichoir View Post
    And for Zodiark to have been locked up, what kind of battle was waged and on what scale to have that outcome. An outcome that is a clear and decisive victory for Hydaelyn, where all calamities, while thus far terrible, still havent spelled defeat or doom for Hydaelyn.
    And what spelled doom for Zodiark?! He is all fine and dandy, having numerous servants each with power that literally one person in the world that have all the blessing that Hydealyn could muster (and lost at one point) can really oppose...He's sealed, but not defeated. His release is only a matter of time however. Not a problem for someone that's probably timeless. I mean, there is no reverse of the calamity. No "world reconstruction" that fixes the seal. It can only go his way or no way at all.

    Quote Originally Posted by Melichoir View Post
    If Hydaelyn remains unchecked, the conclusion is the world gets enveloped by light and destroyed, as demonstrated on other worlds when one side of the spectrum gains to much power (Creatures from the void are from worlds that fell into darkness). So, in making sure things are kept in check, does that means the ascians and their actions are necessary evils?
    No. It means that the Ascians and their actions cause a disruption because if they weren't there, neither would be the warrior of light. And the world would actually be in a state of balance where countries would be hostile towards each other, without waging all-out wars. Garlemald was such a harassed country after all. The three Eorzean states were allied to oppose the actions caused by Ascians, they wouldn't have allied otherwise. By trying to pull the state of the world towards one extreme, the Ascians led to creation of someone that opposes them, allying those countries that otherwise would be contesting for resources, space and what not as most countries do.

    As I said, there ARE things left unknown that will probably show Hydaelyn in less favorable light with time. But the condition of light and dark is actually pretty clear. Just not the actual motives they have because we can only assume that Zodiark wants destruction going by what his "rival" told us. And Ascians do like to beat around the bush themselves instead of saying the thing that the warrior of light would supposedly agree with (if they had better mastery of echo).
    (2)