Faeon, Kalayel, you guys are right that there is likely no need to overmeld with Tier VI materia. It's a luxury. I did it because I happened to have them. When I ran out of VI's, I stopped using VI's for overmelding. You can see that on my pant and boots that I stopped overmelding VI's after running out of them.
However, for the earrings, necklace and bracelets, it's a tough decision. If I use a Tier V cunning on the overmeld, then I'll have 1 fewer CP on each of the accessories. How critical would it be if I were to have 3 fewer CP? No one would know until the future comes. With our current healthy CP pool, it's probably not critical. But I'm a CP-freak, so I'd go to that extreme.
For my hat and gloves, I used Cunning II for the last meld because they happened to be cheaper than Cunning I when I was doing the overmelds.
I probably have gone a bit more craftsmanship than most other people (Competence VI was pretty cheap when I was overmelding my gear, so I kinda went that way...). Some might disagree with my approach. But no one knows what's "right" until 4.4 comes. Anyhow, I still have plenty of room for adding more control. So I'm not worried. And I know as long as I have my max CP, I can make magic happen.
I am now very, very slowly gearing up my DoL classes now. I have all those HQ True Linen/ Nightsteel Ingots crafted already. So there is still plenty of time for me to craft my DoL gear before 4.4 arrives. Stormsap are pretty cheap now, so I can buy a bunch if I have to. I'm still so happy about myself selling all my Stormsap at the beginning of the patch 4.3. I can use that money to buy 3x as much Stormsap now.
Take it easy! Don't break your bank with this! There is still time!
Since long ago, I have given up overmelding mainhand and offhand tools. It's just not worth the money and effort if you had to do it on all your classes. I don't mind doing it on 1 class if I had to use that class a lot on something though. For instance, I did that on my ALC when we had to make a lot of Snailfish Oil back then, and back the oil was over 6K difficulty before it was nerfed. So putting more emphasis on ALC was reasonable.
Thanks for your kind support! I have been slacking off with my DoL in Stormblood. I found that I have been able to get what I need even when I'm a bit undergeared. For instance, my current DoLs are still using i320 with NO overmelds (just in-slot melds). I have only around 700 GP, and I've been doing fine with obtaining everything. I even got lazy with crafting stuff for them, and went for the i330 yellow scrip offhands. Unlike DoH, which I highly value 5 CP from the offhand, have 5 fewer GP from the DoL offhand doens't seem to bother me. My current perception is at the minimum level of 1350, and gathering around 1330, I think. In case you haven't seen it, I've been using my own little table here for gathering. And the rotation I use is a relatively basic one listed on the pic, but it works fine.
![]()




TY for everything. Do you ever do a melding guide for gathering gear? If so I'd love to see it. If not then I'll probably wait for the next items to come out before trying to meld that stuff. Ty again. /bow

Reply With Quote
















