All Greed on Alliance loot

[allgon]

Dumbest idea I have seen in this game after 4 years playing it.
Running Ridorana for the 3rd time, back to back, my chest drops, and the tank gets it.
What motivation do I have to replay it?

They should, at least, give us an option to choose what class gear we can roll NEED, before enter a raid.

[Hakuro89]

Adding more kindling to the fire, I think it's a horrible idea too and can't fathom what they were thinking. It's bad enough that RNG may not smile on you enough for whatever piece you need to drop, but now you have to roll against 7 other people for it every time?

Here's hoping they repeal this ridiculous BS in the next patch.

[Rofel]

Hey mods, any of you taking the feedback in here? The cold shoulder was cute at the beginning but it would be cool to give us a heads up.

[Okamimaru]

I'm only running it for the coin, minion and orchestration rolls... the gear isn't worth the frustration

[Tint]

when at least we could use our own loot rules in pre-formed alliance... this forced greed only is just stupid. and why in the 24 man raids?

but whatever... what's with dungeons? the dungeon gear is already useless on release, so we only get it for selling it for grand company seals anyway. with all greed there it would be more fair. lvling dungeons have a failsafe mechanic anyway with their guaranteed loot at the end. and below lvl 50 we can buy gear from the grand company.

what's with 8 man story raid? the need button is useless there anyway since everyone can roll need on the tokens. and ex primals? they too have a token system already in place to get the gear and for the mounts again everyone has the need button available. they could even remove the need button from savage raids, since you can set up your own loot rules there or you have a static.

but no, they removed the need button from the 24 man raids... the one content wich needed the need button the most...

[OlyverW]

Week 2 lost again on a gear that was an upgrade for me to someone on another class :/

[Rita1989]

I am 2/2 on drops for Samurai running on Warrior which is pretty nice and from what I have seen there has never been more then 2 people rolling a piece of loot and even in the old system you could potentially have up to 5 people rolling against you as dps if your unlucky so this system is a bit more fair for everyone, its more the older raids that suffer more because there is no restriction on rolling and it kind of removes it as an option for returning players to gear up.

[Hakuro89]

I am 2/2 on drops for Samurai running on Warrior which is pretty nice and from what I have seen there has never been more then 2 people rolling a piece of loot and even in the old system you could potentially have up to 5 people rolling against you as dps if your unlucky so this system is a bit more fair for everyone, its more the older raids that suffer more because there is no restriction on rolling and it kind of removes it as an option for returning players to gear up.

Right out of the gate hitting 50/60 they have better gear available than what drops out of those raids.

[Rita1989]

Right out of the gate hitting 50/60 they have better gear available than what drops out of those raids.

Rabanstre drops 330 though which is catchup gear to get to min ilvl for Swallows Compass and deltascape

[Hakuro89]

Rabanstre drops 330 though which is catchup gear to get to min ilvl for Swallows Compass and deltascape

And that greed only lock still applies to it. Please don't try to defend this just because you're one of the few that got lucky with it.