Late season dies out, for a catalogue of reasons, here are some of them in the hope they actually read this section.
- The queues are long. A player distribution issue as opposed to game design. The problem, which is game design related is the wait is so long for so little. I played 6 games last week and won 5, all in the same day. I stopped, getting +100 as Diamond is hard and takes a couple hours of queueing as ranged due to length. Even when I was Plat id log out some days at +80-100 because I thought it was good enough progress before I start losing, go on a tilt and play badly.
-In reference to point 1, you have to win almost twice as many games as lost to progress. Again, when your queues are 12-22 minutes, this is an issue. 30 minutes later you've lost 27 points. 30 minutes after that you lose another 27.. That's an hour already gone out of maybe the 2-3 hours you have to play a day and you now need around 3 wins at 23ish points each to break even. Assuming you win 3 in a row, which is entirely down to what team you have in a lot of cases (inb4 "nature of solo queue" - it is, but it doesn't make it less painful) that's already another hour. Let's say you play your third hour, you get 3 games in that hour and lose 1 and win 2. 3 hours to get 7 rating. You can now see why when I got +100, I took it and ran. It's not about having nothing to lose, at 2161 I'm safe, even if there was decay I'd literally just play the bare minimum, in the time I spend queueing on this game I could be actively enjoying ANYTHING else, including offline. But when people have nothing to lose as well, when they tilt, no queues are safe. Commence job rouletting and game throwing. They'll get banned for it eventually, but the damage has already been done.
-Referencing point 2; like any ranked game, safe ratings exist. I sat on WoW at 3k in S22 because it was guaranteed R1. An hour of games could put it out of permanent reach for the last couple of weeks, why risk it. That risk doesn't apply here, I played Feast because I enjoyed it, but as more and more good players stop playing, your games become endless frustration, which synergizes with the other issues that you can be left deep in a hole that you can't get out of, pointswise. If training had an incentive for people to play it, I'd be there. Atm we play customs on Chaos and we enjoy them, because we have fun, equal games (some not so equal, but because rating isn't on the line, we're happy to leave our lobbies open for newbies to give it a try as they're the future for our queues, the earlier they learn the better especially since low ranked queues and training are dead). If I had the opportunity to play Healer outside of ranked more often, I'd still be queueing in Diamond as AST just for something different and because the queues aren't as bad. However I'm not good enough to simply jump in, I'm not going to wreck other peoples' already minimal stunted progress by attempting it.
-The foundations are there for new players to try feast, but encouragement and incentives are not. The top 100 is looked upon as a place they won't reach (despite the fact people like Ardo [correct me if I'm wrong, but it's his first season and he's top 10] and Piush are pretty much in safe range). The rewards at lower tiers are a joke and aside from tomes you are not proactively rewarded sufficiently for how you progress in a season.
-Light Medals are a frustrating new mechanic. Again, why queue to deal with the frustration of having an amazing game where we kill ranged and melee in the first minute, and subsequently suffer either trying to kill them with LM stacks, tunnelling their healer or killing near invincible stanced tanks (outside of culling) - only to lose in the last couple of minutes because they LB all our medals off us during culling and we couldn't respond effectively due to their reduced damage taken. We're forced to play defensive at the end of games because it's' easier than trying to kill anything, they've said they're going to address this but I don't have high hopes for it being changed for the better. LM should just be removed. If a team is dominating, let them win - they've earned it. Never ever played a game that punishes you so harshly for being ahead.
-Some of the most fun jobs are also almost the most useless. Starting with SMN (I know Feves is going to chew me for this later). SMN is balanced on the assumption that they can Bahamut burst after DWT. Bahamut functions badly enough in PvE, it''s even worse in feast. You have no guarantee you will land an Akh Morn when you want it to land, let alone it actually landing at all. As a result in some games SMN is either extremely strong with great quick burst phases or performs extremely poorly. Furthermore, the fact that Aetherflow CD doesn't reset when a SMN dies is just ridiculous. It was the same weakness SMN/SCH had in HW, if I see SMN aetherflow idc if he's got LM stacks if we're close to a burst I'm calling him next, because he'll be useless for like half a minute after.
-Finally, as this is class balance related. Paladin is simply too strong and also another reason I've avoided queues on occasion. They aren't fun to play against, a team with a Paladin vs team without one can make so many more mistakes and have an extremely easy game. The other has to play mindgames and pull off crazy hard switches to make good ground, or wait for the PLD to make a mistake. CC is so short in this game that simply binding the PLD when he runs for a stun on healer is not frequently feasible. Giving a tank a ranged silence and allowing them to split damage in a game mode where the only way to do anything is to burst single targets (as pressure does absolutely nothing, hence why SMN is not nearly as strong as it should be as a dot job) is simply obscene.
I like the new combat system, but for frontlines it's truly boring. There's no reason to do them too boring to even cap tomes in them. Once you're rank 50 that's all folks. I've been sitting on 20k wolf marks for a couple of years now, I spent a few once in a while on random glams but I get capped within an hour again. I was so bored late season I resubbed to RuneScape.
As it stands, this game is currently better off without a ranked mode, unless they can resurrect Light Party, because I don't think I can be bothered with S8 (and won't bother if the reward is an S7 mount reskin) and feel it isn't worth the stress.
If you want to get involved mate, come to Wolf Pups Den discord and join the custom games we make, literally only chance you have.