Here you go Yoshida, hard-straight stats.

[Rokien]

I hate the need/greed system, how can you deem someone that needs something? YOU DON'T NEED ANYTHING! YOU WANT EVERYTHING! Everyone will just either do greed>need. It's a terrible system that doesn't need to be implemented and it's a waist of resources

[Answa]

I hate the need/greed system, how can you deem someone that needs something? YOU DON'T NEED ANYTHING! YOU WANT EVERYTHING! Everyone will just either do greed>need. It's a terrible system that doesn't need to be implemented and it's a waist of resources

waste*

It's a refined lotting system. Even if everyone hits on "need" when it's just "greed" it's a randomized process that goes back to just lotting on things.

[Jinko]

I hate the need/greed system, how can you deem someone that needs something? YOU DON'T NEED ANYTHING! YOU WANT EVERYTHING! Everyone will just either do greed>need. It's a terrible system that doesn't need to be implemented and it's a waist of resources

It's just a modified /random roll.

I see no point in having the weapon drop and then a npc-tradable item as well, it would be better to just have the npc-tradable item IMO.
SE never do things the easy way though. WHY IS THIS !! ??

Just another flaw to the list. I'm getting REALLY curious to see what excuse the dev team will use when we migrate to 2.0 servers...because right now it's always the current server's fault.

PS3 limitations of course, worked well enough for them in FF11.

I'm happy to hear they are doing a token-like system but I'm not sure I like their implementation. I think it'd be better if it was untradable but dropped for each person.

Exactly, everyone should get a 1 token per fight and then say after collecting 10 you can buy your weapon.

I would be totally happy with that, gives me something to work towards.

I agree completely. Making only the tokens tradable has far more potential for abuse than just weapons. I can already see groups offering to take a leech on a run and sell tokens for exorbitant amounts of gil.

Where did it say the tokens would be tradable between PC players ?
Common sense tells me they would only be tradable to an NPC, but then I suppose I shouldn't let common sense fool me, it is SE we are talking about.

[Lienn]

PS3 limitations of course, worked well enough for them in FF11.

LOL!

Very true...i forgot about this one.