Can we replace Silent Dusk?

[KDSilver]

Scholar already has Chain Stratagem and Fey Wind. It's strong enough.
Another damage buff would make scholar overpowered.

Silent dusk is indeed extremely situationnal, but i feel like they don't change it because scholar already has a lot of tool at his disposal.

[basketofseals]

Silent dusk is indeed extremely situationnal, but i feel like they don't change it because scholar already has a lot of tool at his disposal.

It's not situational, it's useless. If you have her on sic she'll blow it on uninterruptible casts, and if you have it her on obey, who knows if she'll even get it off? Recognize that a spell is being cast, that the spell can be interrupted, command Selene, wait for Selene to recognize you commanded her, wait for her GCD to reset, apply the silence, then hope to god that the server even registers the silence even applying before the server says the cast is finished. Unless we see a massive improvement in pet responsiveness or we start seeing 5+ second cast times, no group will ever even consider Silent Dusk.