Can we replace Silent Dusk?

[Ametrine]

Because outside of that, Scholar still has everything he needs to fulfill its job fantastically.
Ast had a lot of problem during all Heavensward because he had less healing and his buff couldn't compete with White Mage's power.

Honestly, yes it is useless and Eos is way better but Scholar doesn't need anything more so...

Probably. But, AST cards got tweaked for SB, too, and for the better. Right now, the biggest issue they face is Spire being a fodder card, but that's still a better place that Selene's Silent Dusk.

I still stand by Silent Dusk being made instant, not reliant on the need to interrupt Embrace. It would be less of a buff, more a full on repair of the skill. If we could simply allow it's utility to be used, Selene would be fine!

(Although I would like each faerie type to get a separate Aetherpact effect, oh well.)

[KDSilver]

My point is, i'm afraid of how they could change Silent Dusk.
Cause if they give it a powerful change, I fear that they'll nerf Scholar too much in another patch because they'll feel he's too strong.

That's why I'm mixed.
I'd really like it to be a useful tool, but when you see how the dev team balance jobs sometimes... ^^"

(in other words Kabzy, i'm not saying classes that perform well shouldn't have attention)

[NobleWinter]

Selene needs to replace everything except embrace.

Lev. 1 Fey Caress
Ability- 25 Sec Recast
Remove one detrimental status effect from a single party member.
Additional Effect: Restores HP. Cure Potency 200

Lev. 40 Fey Wind
Ability - 60 Sec Recast
Reduce both Weapon and Spell Cast/Recast Time and Auto Attack delay by 2% for 60 seconds.

Lev. 20 Clamoring Dusk
Spell - 2 Sec Cast/ 60 Sec Recast
Restore HP to all party members within 20 yalms.
Cure Potency 300.

This way Rouse would be effective for both pets with no useless Silence and terribly under utilized group cleanse either.