Using AST's Expand in Light Party Duties

[Risvertasashi]

Most random ASTs probably don't even realize that expanded nerfs the card in exchange.

There is nothing wrong with expanded balance and so forth, even in light parties. Well, unless one DPS is 5k and the other is 1k. But if they're close enough, and tank and healer and DPSing, it's still a good gain. And even if there is a large disparity, sometimes you just have to roll with what RNGsus gives you.

[Nyxn607]

It is fine if you use a 3rd party program to keep track of dps. However it is still against the terms and most people don't use one. Not to mention ps4 players don't have the option. So without that little illegal tool, it is really just a best guess. I agree that you shouldn't put balance on a dps that dies 3-4 times a fight, but if a dps is using their kit properly, they should rarely stay at the #2 or #3 position on aggro list.

If you have a good way of determining how to know without use of the 3rd party, please let me know. I am genuinely curious.

[Risvertasashi]

If you have a good way of determining how to know without use of the 3rd party, please let me know. I am genuinely curious.

You have 2 options ultimately.
1. Embrace the "don't ask, don't tell" policy and use a parser, but don't use it to shame people (which is what SE really cares about).
2. Play a subpar buffing AST, making 'best guesses'.

The nature of the job is you need to make informed decisions to play well.

[HyoMinPark]

It is fine if you use a 3rd party program to keep track of dps. However it is still against the terms and most people don't use one. Not to mention ps4 players don't have the option. So without that little illegal tool, it is really just a best guess. I agree that you shouldn't put balance on a dps that dies 3-4 times a fight, but if a dps is using their kit properly, they should rarely stay at the #2 or #3 position on aggro list.

The bolded of this isn't true, because DPS that actually monitor their own aggro use aggro dumps when they need to; I can frequently climb to #2 on the aggro list on BRD, hit Refresh or Tactician, and drop down to #6, but still be the highest or second highest DPS; on the other hand, I can not be the highest DPS, but still be #2 just because BRD is ridiculous with regards to the amount of aggro it produces. Also, a healer that spams AOE heals can easily climb to #2 or #3 on the aggro list, but be doing zero DPS. Enmity list is not a good way to determine DPS rank when it comes to dishing out cards. But don't want to turn this into a parser debate, since this isn't really what this thread is about.

[Zojha]

I can not be the highest DPS, but still be #2 just because BRD is ridiculous with regards to the amount of aggro it produces.

Out of curiosity: Care to elaborate how this is possible?

From my understanding, you generate aggro from using abilities (which gives a flat amount of aggro) and doing damage, where the damage you do = the aggro you generate. Tank abilities and healing abilities are the only abilities I know of that have modifiers. Where would the Bard aggro come from?

[Ghishlain]

Out of curiosity: Care to elaborate how this is possible?

From my understanding, you generate aggro from using abilities (which gives a flat amount of aggro) and doing damage, where the damage you do = the aggro you generate. Tank abilities and healing abilities are the only abilities I know of that have modifiers. Where would the Bard aggro come from?

I'm not a Bard main but if I would take a guess it would be a combination of the following:

1. Bard openers are very powerful from what I understand, leading to huge spike in enmity at the beginning
2. DPS opening with Diversion - this means they can open hard but still generate less aggro overall resulting in a lower starting enmity compared to BRD
3. BRD only have enmity dumps where as melee DPS only have the ability to lower their enmity accumulation temporarily (DRG being an exception due to Elusive Jump). This can lead into BRD aggro going above melee DPS before being dropped suddenly from use of Tacticians or Refresh. This is especially true when you compare BRD to NIN given the number of enmity tools NIN have available, allowing them to maintain very high damage with little fear of over taking the tanks. In a boss fight in a 4-man dungeon, I can definitely see BRD having a higher enmity than NIN but the NIN still doing more damage. Likewise for a DRG making liberal use of Elusive Jump to do mechanics as that's a 30s CD with an enmity dump attached.

[Zojha]

I'm not a Bard main but if I would take a guess it would be a combination of the following [...]

Well, you're explaining a different phenomenon entirely. The person I quoted claimed you can be top of the aggro without being top of the DPS as Bard solely because the job generates a lot of enmity - Not because other people have used their enmity tools, those tools were mentioned separately. And that confuses me because it goes against how I thought enmity in this game works.

A bursty opener generates a lot of aggro because it does a lot of damage - that makes perfect sense. A DPS simply generating a lot of aggro without also generating DPS... less so. To me anyway. But going over that in great detail would just derail the thread I guess.


Edit: I see. It was bad phrasing.

[Risvertasashi]

Well, you're explaining a different phenomenon entirely. The person I quoted claimed you can be top of the aggro without being top of the DPS as Bard solely because the job generates a lot of enmity

You're right in that it's the other way around. Modifiers are negative, otherwise all DPS jobs would be equal, and aggro actually would be a "better than nothing" way to gauge relative DPS.

[HyoMinPark]

Out of curiosity: Care to elaborate how this is possible?

From my understanding, you generate aggro from using abilities (which gives a flat amount of aggro) and doing damage, where the damage you do = the aggro you generate. Tank abilities and healing abilities are the only abilities I know of that have modifiers. Where would the Bard aggro come from?

Bard burst is insanely high. Take my static for example. A lot of them can pop Diversion (MNK and NIN can), but BRD doesn't have such an ability to use during its opener (we can only pop Tactician/Refresh after the fact for it to have any effect on our aggro). By our MNK and NIN quelling their initial aggro, BRD can easily surpass them in terms of enmity because we don't have Diversion (because we don't need to give a job with an 8k burst any form of aggro quelling, no...absolutely not >.>). The MNK or NIN can be top DPS, but be lower than me on the enmity list because they have quelling options for their opener. I do not. (Funnily enough, the NIN in my static actually has to Smokescreen me so that I don't rip the boss off of the MT during my opener. The times he forgets to, I usually always rip hate... getting bopped by Hali or Exdeath = not fun.)

[Silver-Strider]

Bard burst is insanely high. Take my static for example. A lot of them can pop Diversion (MNK and NIN can), but BRD doesn't have such an ability to use during its opener (we can only pop Tactician/Refresh after the fact for it to have any effect on our aggro). By our MNK and NIN quelling their initial aggro, BRD can easily surpass them in terms of enmity because we don't have Diversion (because we don't need to give a job with an 8k burst any form of aggro quelling, no...absolutely not >.>). The MNK or NIN can be top DPS, but be lower than me on the enmity list because they have quelling options for their opener. I do not. (Funnily enough, the NIN in my static actually has to Smokescreen me so that I don't rip the boss off of the MT during my opener. The times he forgets to, I usually always rip hate... getting bopped by Hali or Exdeath = not fun.)

Tell your NIN to stop being lazy and smoke bomb you lol